18 Nov '07 04:00>
Here is a traditional Zen koan—
___________________________________
A man once made a home for a small goose in a large bottle. The goose was free to leave the bottle and return as he wished. But, by and by, the goose grew too large and one day became stuck in the bottle.
The man did not wish to break the bottle, nor did he wish to hurt the goose.
How will you get the goose out of the bottle?
___________________________________
Koans point to an existential dilemma, and cannot be “solved” intellectually; they are not about theorizing.
Nevertheless, I thought I would present one—without further commentary on metaphor or symbolism (which might be clear to someone in an “eastern” culture)—to see how various people might interpret it. Just out of curiosity.
___________________________________
A man once made a home for a small goose in a large bottle. The goose was free to leave the bottle and return as he wished. But, by and by, the goose grew too large and one day became stuck in the bottle.
The man did not wish to break the bottle, nor did he wish to hurt the goose.
How will you get the goose out of the bottle?
___________________________________
Koans point to an existential dilemma, and cannot be “solved” intellectually; they are not about theorizing.
Nevertheless, I thought I would present one—without further commentary on metaphor or symbolism (which might be clear to someone in an “eastern” culture)—to see how various people might interpret it. Just out of curiosity.