15 Jan '10 15:33>
Originally posted by quackquackYes, a playoff would cause lots of arguments. That's part of what would make it so much fun. It's what makes the NCAA basketball season so much fun when "bubble season" starts a week or so before they release the brackets.
There is no way that a playoff does not ruin rivalries and dilute the previously played games. I also think it would still cause a tremendous number of arguements. Take the USA today poll. If you had a 8 team play off based on their top eight. There would be three big 10 teams, 2 SEC teams, 2 non-BCS teams and one Big 12 team. Do you think the ACC an ...[text shortened]... hampion in which everyone who might have a claim to be the best gets their chance on the field.
As for rivalries. There aren't as many of them as you think. There's plenty of room on everyone's schedule to maintain any true rivalries that a playoff system might endanger. Just get rid of Ghost Town St. and replace it with your rivalry of choice. Of course, THAT would generate lots of arguments. Fine. Let them whine.