Originally posted by uzless
of course not, considering that the 8th payroll team is so much closer to the rest of the lower payroll teams that the top 4 are. Being 6, 7, or 8 doesn't guarantee much but being 1,2,3, or 4 usually does.
This really isn't that hard to understand.
Your complaint simply does not show the true picture.
(1) Small markets teams such as Tampa and the Twins continually make the playoffs.
(2) We have divisions like the AL and NL central where small market teams primarily play against each other and get a playoff spot even if teams like Boston, New York and Philly are better.
(3) There is huge revenue sharing so the more big teams spend the more small market teams get.
(4) There is a draft and bad teams get the opportunity to get the best shot of future stars while the good teams simply don't get that opportunity. Thus players like Strausberg and Mauer who people think are can't miss stars go to teams that did worse and are paid far less than they would be if they were free agents.
(5) There is compensation for signing free agents and in a post steriod era free agents have been less and less reliable.
Finally, and to me most importantl. MLB is not an intramural sport if you want a team you need to do more than just pay a franchise fee you need to have investment in the team. The higher payroll teams have made the investments (and so have their fans) and the teams that just pocket revenue sharing deserve what they get.