Go back
A separate religion forum?

A separate religion forum?

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Every time I visit the debate forum these days I'm swamped in threads about bloody God. 'The concept of sin', 'atonement theology', 'why organised religion is a crock', BLAH, BLAH, BLAH. Every one of these threads is a) dull, dull, dull and b) totally devoid of any element of debate. Apparently it's impossible to debate whether or not God exists - it's only possible to shout about it.

Now, I like a good argument as much as anyone, but I don't think I've ever in my life bothered to argue about religion with anyone. There's just so many more interesting things to talk about, like wars, and extra-marital affairs and student tuition fees...

So to get to the point of the thread heading, why not create a whole new forum for people who like to shout at each other about God? Then we could keep this one nice and clear for proper things that actually affect people (and religion in a political context would of course be tolerated - if grudgingly).

Erm, anyone agree?

Rich.

Vote Up
Vote Down

i agree...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Yes, get the stupid God botherers out of the main stream and into the back waters where they belong.

Vote Up
Vote Down

I agree. That way only those actually interested in those debates will be reading those.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Awesome Idee!
(There's really not much to debate about when it comes to religion)

Vote Up
Vote Down

I'd agree, but unfortunately even if a religion forum comes true it wont really work.

You still need an audience to hear you if you're shouting.

MÅ¥HÅRM

Vote Up
Vote Down

agreed

Vote Up
Vote Down

on the whole it would work...alas there are 1 or 2 (okay just 1) people here who are on a mission to 'spread the word' ...i don't think it would stop him from hijacking other threads

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mayharm
I'd agree, but unfortunately even if a religion forum comes true it wont really work.

You still need an audience to hear you if you're shouting.

MÅ¥HÅRM
you beat me to it 🙂

Vote Up
Vote Down

Maybe we could start a petition right here?

Rich.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Sure...why not.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by richhoey
Now, I like a good argument as much as anyone, but I don't think I've ever in my life bothered to argue about religion with anyone. There's just so many more interesting things to talk about, like wars, and extra-marital affairs and student tuition fees...
Student tuition fees?!?!

I know religious discussions can get tiresome, but so can any worn-out subject. I'd say the war in Iraq/Bush is an idiot threads are just as bad as any religious threads...

...yet I find myself participating in them. They certainly are of broader interest than tuition fees. I would have to vote 'no' on moving religion to a separate forum.

Vote Up
Vote Down

the problem lies with religion being forced into threads which were not originally a religious thread...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Pcaspian agreed to this idea, so It is my duty to disagree with him. I say religious arguments stay where they are!

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rwingett
Pcaspian agreed to this idea, so It is my duty to disagree with him. I say religious arguments stay where they are!
haha...yes, i never spotted that.