Go back
A two-sentence  enlightenment.

A two-sentence enlightenment.

Debates


Apple depends on consumer to buy product

Consumer depends on Apple to MAKE product!

On the other side of AvJoe logic, the socialist* consumer depends on government for EVERYTHING.
Government depends on Consumer for NOTHING .

This should do it for you who do not know which way is up.

* Oh, for the record, socialism is for the people, NOT for the Socialists, who live on the hill!


@AverageJoe1 said
Apple depends on consumer to buy product

Consumer depends on Apple to MAKE product!

On the other side of AvJoe logic, the socialist* consumer depends on government for EVERYTHING.
Government depends on Consumer for NOTHING .

This should do it for you who do not know which way is up.

* Oh, for the record, socialism is for the people, NOT for the Socialists, who live on the hill!
No consumer "depends" on Apple. If Apple disappears tomorrow Androids will just become more popular.

Your logic breaks down by your second sentence.

The government depends on citizens for taxes to fund the government. 2 false statements already.


@vivify said
No consumer "depends" on Apple. If Apple disappears tomorrow Androids will just become more popular.

Your logic breaks down by your second sentence.

The government depends on citizens for taxes to fund the government. 2 false statements already.
Really? Set aside that you anre arguing the literal wording while missing the economic principle entirely.

Of course consumers can switch from Apple to Android, Geez. But That actually *supports* my point Apple must continuallly persuade consumers to buy its products through innovation, quality, pricing, and service. If it fails, consumers can take their money elsewhere, and apple suffers the consequences. The consumer has a choice; Apple has to earn the sale, you see. Econ 101, small thinker. Know you nothing of capitalism? I wonder if you know socialism

Now compare that with government, if you are still there😄?. Government doesn’t have to persuade citizens individually to voluntarily purchase its services.It can compel them to pay taxes, whether they approve of its performance or not. Citizens have political recourse, of course, but theycannot simply opt out of their tax obligation because they dislike the product.

And your claim that government depends on citizens for taxes doesn’t disprove my argument. It confuses the source of government revenue with theMECHANISM BY WHICH IT IS COLLECTED .Think for a change, Sonhouse. Yes, government needs revenue. But unlike Apple, it doesn’t have to win each citizen’s voluntary purchase to obtain it

So, follow me,,,,,the marketplace disciplines businesses through consumer choice; government exercises powers that private businesses do not possess. Ah hah, you get it now. I’ve tayght this stuff.

My point about socialism is that when government assumes responsibility for an everexpanding share of economic life, citizens become increasingly dependent on political decisions rather than voluntary exchange, competition, and individual initiative. Increasingly dependent, zMrSocialist.

Your bringing in Android above, quite a weak start, but, I read on

1 edit

@AverageJoe1 said
Really? Set aside that you anre arguing the literal wording while missing the economic principle entirely.

Of course consumers can switch from Apple to Android, Geez. But That actually *supports* my point Apple must continuallly persuade consumers to buy its products through innovation, quality, pricing, and service. If it fails, consumers can take their money else ...[text shortened]... ingly dependent, zMrSocialist.

Your bringing in Android above, quite a weak start, but, I read on
When you say government depends on citizens "for nothing", that's your fault for poor communication if that's not what you meant.

You said the marketplaces disciplines businesses; that's only partially true. Businesses manipulate markets; the bigger the business, the more power it has to do so. This can include paying off politicians or crushing smaller businesses so competition doesn't exist.


@vivify said
When you say government depends on citizens "for nothing", that's your fault for poor communication if that's not what you meant.

You said the marketplaces disciplines businesses; that's only partially true. Businesses manipulate markets; the bigger the business, the more power it has to do so. This can include paying off politicians or crushing smaller businesses so competition doesn't exist.
Right , we do not want corporations to abuse, no more than we want government to abuse. So that is really just saying the obvious. I don't have to argue that markets have to be perfect to defend free enterprise. I can acknowledge market failures while asking whether a proposed government solution will work, what it will cost, and how it will be held accountable. That is my beef. Tell us a perfect solution?
That is pretty much it in a nutshell. You liberals seem to always think that things should be perfect. I can defend that by saying there’s NOTHING perfect about taking the labor of another for yourself. Note that I have asked that before, and none of you will ever take exception to it. This, it would follow that You have to agree


@AverageJoe1 said
there’s NOTHING perfect about taking the labor of another for yourself.
Agreed. That's why I'm not pro-communism. I don't think it can work in most modern societies.

Though I respect the ideal of socialism, I'm not anti-capitalist. I think capitalism is a good thing as long as it is kept in check.


@vivify said
Agreed. That's why I'm not pro-communism. I don't think it can work in most modern societies.

Though I respect the ideal of socialism, I'm not anti-capitalist. I think capitalism is a good thing as long as it is kept in check.
Of course.
Hey, I just saw some liberal forum members running by the front door, I think there is a riot downtown. I asked them what it was and one of them said “I don’t know what it’s about… “but they were heading out..
A life to envy.! Angst in their blood.


@vivify said
Agreed. That's why I'm not pro-communism. I don't think it can work in most modern societies.

Though I respect the ideal of socialism, I'm not anti-capitalist. I think capitalism is a good thing as long as it is kept in check.
" taking the labor of another for yourself" is the very basis of capitalism.


@AverageJoe1 said
Apple depends on consumer to buy product

Consumer depends on Apple to MAKE product!

On the other side of AvJoe logic, the socialist* consumer depends on government for EVERYTHING.
Government depends on Consumer for NOTHING .

This should do it for you who do not know which way is up.

* Oh, for the record, socialism is for the people, NOT for the Socialists, who live on the hill!
Who do you depend on?


@AThousandYoung said
Who do you depend on?
I depend on my own work, personal responsibility, voluntary cooperation, and the freedom to make my own choices. Government has a role, but my life shouldn’t depend on government control. Soo simple.
You cannot handle this, Thousand. You just cannot. You will not be able to respond to it, except as a normal human, or as Susie, or as Sunhouse, bless him.
but man, the whole forum society would sure like to see you respond to it. You can’t, man. I hate it for you, but it could be a learning experience. Feel free to contact me by PN. your friend average joke.


@AverageJoe1 said
I depend on my own work, personal responsibility, voluntary cooperation, and the freedom to make my own choices. Government has a role, but my life shouldn’t depend on government control. Soo simple.
You cannot handle this, Thousand. You just cannot. You will not be able to respond to it, except as a normal human, or as Susie, or as Sunhouse, bless him.
...[text shortened]... you, but it could be a learning experience. Feel free to contact me by PN. your friend average joke.
So you don’t fit into the simplistic description of free market economics that you just started this thread with.

I stopped reading when you said you “depend on your own work”.

You don’t make your own iPhone so how are you posting on this website?


@AverageJoe1 said
Apple depends on consumer to buy product

Consumer depends on Apple to MAKE product!

On the other side of AvJoe logic, the socialist* consumer depends on government for EVERYTHING.
Government depends on Consumer for NOTHING .

This should do it for you who do not know which way is up.

* Oh, for the record, socialism is for the people, NOT for the Socialists, who live on the hill!
America's government is supposed to be "of the people, by the people, for the people".

NOT "of the corporation, by the corporation, for the corporation".

NOT "of the president, by the president, for the president".


@AThousandYoung said
So you don’t fit into the simplistic description of free market economics that you just started this thread with.

I stopped reading when you said you “depend on your own work”.

You don’t make your own iPhone so how are you posting on this website?
What a fool. SHouse, Sue…sure you don’t want to shy away from this loser?!?

You stopped reading because I said I depend on my own work? That’s exactly the point. You see, depending on my own work doesn’t mean I’m independent of other people. I rely on customers, coworkers, infrastructure, and voluntary exchange. Free-market economics recognizes that interdependence. The disagreement is whether cooperation should primarily be voluntary or directed by government. If you want to debate my position, address what I actually said rather than dismissing it after one sentence.
My point is that self-reliance and interdependence are not opposites. You can recognize how much upu RELY ON OTHERS while still believing individuals should have as much freedom and responsibility as possible in making their own choices.
All you can write to such a clear AvJoe statement is is total dribble. I frankly will be entertained when you do it.. I will chalk this up as a win for me in advance. You got nuthin. Pitiful parasites is…. Nothing.

Pitiful you are.


@AverageJoe1 said
That is pretty much it in a nutshell. You liberals seem to always think that things should be perfect. I can defend that by saying there’s NOTHING perfect about taking the labor of another for yourself. Note that I have asked that before, and none of you will ever take exception to it. This, it would follow that You have to agree
Will you PLEASE drop this nonsense?

No one is saying this, no one is advocating this.

This is something you've made up in the dark recesses of your mind, and now it is your gospel, because in your dim bulb brain, it answers all your questions. Never mind that no one has said this.


@AverageJoe1 said
What a fool. SHouse, Sue…sure you don’t want to shy away from this loser?!?

You stopped reading because I said I depend on my own work? That’s exactly the point. You see, depending on my own work doesn’t mean I’m independent of other people. I rely on customers, coworkers, infrastructure, and voluntary exchange. Free-market economics recognizes that interdependence. ...[text shortened]... p as a win for me in advance. You got nuthin. Pitiful parasites is…. Nothing.

Pitiful you are.
More of the same drivel.