@Suzianne saidOK. I respect your comment. So let us ferret this out with a foundation upon which to discuss. I agree.
Will you PLEASE drop this nonsense?
No one is saying this, no one is advocating this.
This is something you've made up in the dark recesses of your mind, and now it is your gospel, because in your dim bulb brain, it answers all your questions. Never mind that no one has said this.
The foundation is that no one person is entitled to the labor of another. First, can we stipulate to that?
@AverageJoe1 saidI agree. That also goes for times when you're not able to help yourself.
My point is that self-reliance and interdependence are not opposites.
Example: someone suffers a heart attack and needs others get him to the hospital; if that heart attack is debilitating enough, he may need to be cared for.
However, you draw the line when the assistance needed is financial. That line you draw seems quite arbitrary. You assume people who need financial assistance are just bums leeching off the system.
Many reasons lead to financial instability; see that heart-attack example; supposed it's a family member like a spouse who can no longer contribute financially; if a wife now has to support her husband, is she a leech for needing food stamps?
If you understand that interdependence is necessary, you shouldn't draw arbitrary boundaries like needing public assistance, since you don't know what factors may have lead to that need.
1 edit
@Suzianne saidWhat a dumb comment, you were just fine with bidens handlers and cancel culture and all of the other woke bs that actually went on.
America's government is supposed to be "of the people, by the people, for the people".
NOT "of the corporation, by the corporation, for the corporation".
NOT "of the president, by the president, for the president".
I’m still waiting for you and number man to tell me all of the names of those put to death and then found innocent. He said there were lots and lots name a few in the last 30, 50, 70, years?
@vivify saidOk. And thank you for a thoughtful response.
I agree. That also goes for times when you're not able to help yourself.
Example: someone suffers a heart attack and needs others get him to the hospital; if that heart attack is debilitating enough, he may need to be cared for.
However, you draw the line when the assistance needed is financial. That line you draw seems quite arbitrary. You assume people who need ...[text shortened]... daries like needing public assistance, since you don't know what factors may have lead to that need.
I agree with you that people can fall into financial hardship through no fault of their own. A heart attack, a disabled spouse, a job loss, or an unexpected tragedy can happen to responsible, hardworking people. I don’t consider someone a ‘leech’ simply because they need assistance, and I don’t think needing help should strip anyone of their dignity.
Where we may differ is not whether people should help one another, but how that help should be provided, who should be responsible for it, and how we ensure the system is fair andsustainable. I believe in personal responsibility, but I also believe in compasssion and helping people who genuinely cannot help themselves. I just don’t believe that acknowledging our interdependence automatically means every form of government assistance is justified or that government is always the best way to provide it.
So let me ask you this sincerely: …. C’mon.. Do you believe there should be any limits or conditions on public assistance, and if so, what should they be? I’m interested in understanding where you draw that line, just as you ask where I am drawing. Thline.
Believing in self-reliance does not require believing that everyone can manage every hardship alone. You can support a safety net while still debating its scope, funding, and design. That gives you common ground from which to have a more productive discussion.
@AverageJoe1 saidSince tragedy can happen to any one of us, we all should be responsible for helping each other. Any one of us can be affected by a fire, so it's far that our tax money is used for firefighting. Same for financial hardship.
Where we may differ is not whether people should help one another, but how that help should be provided, who should be responsible for it, and how we ensure the system is fair andsustainable.
How to ensure the system is "fair" and not being exploited? That's more difficult and I don't have an answer to that.
https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/tg61
In the link above, the multi-billion-dollar corporation AIG misused bailout money when the CEOs gave themselves raises with it. They were punished with fines.
This came to light because there were records accounting for how this money was used. Perhaps something similar should be done with all forms of public assistance.
@AverageJoe1
So we look at Maslow: What people really need is eating, clothing housing and relationsships. Iphones are very expendibale.
Producers like people to think that their product is not only worthwhile, but necessary for a decent living. As long as enough consumers believe it is accepted as truth.
@mike69 said"Since 1973, more than 165 people who have been sentenced to death have been exonerated. "
What a dumb comment, you were just fine with bidens handlers and cancel culture and all of the other woke bs that actually went on.
I’m still waiting for you and number man to tell me all of the names of those put to death and then found innocent. He said there were lots and lots name a few in the last 30, 50, 70, years?
https://mtinnocenceproject.org/5-innocent-people-who-were-executed-or-exonerated-on-death-row/
Would that qualify as "lots"?
@no1marauder saidIt's up to 203 now:
"Since 1973, more than 165 people who have been sentenced to death have been exonerated. "
https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/policy/innocence
2 edits
@no1marauder saidHow many have been executed then found innocent after. I found a 1955 case and some from 1915 to 1939. List the names from the last 20 to 30 years with the date that were EXECUTED I don’t need those that were not executed and let out.
"Since 1973, more than 165 people who have been sentenced to death have been exonerated. "
https://mtinnocenceproject.org/5-innocent-people-who-were-executed-or-exonerated-on-death-row/
Would that qualify as "lots"?
@mike69 saidCameron Todd William.
Can you read the question and answer correctly? I’ve been through your liberal sources doing the same as you, no.2, sue, and tds man.
The state of Texas charged a prosecutor for knowingly withholding evidence of his innocence:
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/texas-bar-charges-willingham-prosecutor-with-misconduct/
Withholding information lead to the execution of man for a crime forensic scientists have since found he should not have been convicted of.
@vivify saidDate he was executed and found innocent after.
Cameron Todd William.
The state of Texas charged a prosecutor for knowingly withholding evidence of his innocence:
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/texas-bar-charges-willingham-prosecutor-with-misconduct/
Withholding information lead to the execution of man for a crime forensic scientists have since found he should not have been convicted of.
@vivify saidLegally, it is a claim: Officially, Willingham was never posthumously exonerated or pardoned. The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles unanimously denied a petition for a posthumous pardon in 2014. Therefore, the state of Texas still legally considers him guilty.
Cameron Todd William.
The state of Texas charged a prosecutor for knowingly withholding evidence of his innocence:
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/texas-bar-charges-willingham-prosecutor-with-misconduct/
Withholding information lead to the execution of man for a crime forensic scientists have since found he should not have been convicted of.
@mike69 saidhttps://abcnews.com/US/tommy-lee-walker-exonerated-70-years-after-execution/story?id=129465114
Legally, it is a claim: Officially, Willingham was never posthumously exonerated or pardoned. The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles unanimously denied a petition for a posthumous pardon in 2014. Therefore, the state of Texas still legally considers him guilty.
Tommy Lee Walker, exonerated after execution.