Go back
Amnesty report on war in Ukraine

Amnesty report on war in Ukraine

Debates


@kevcvs57 said
I was asking for a link to the claim by vivify concerning the Ukrainian forces treatment of ethnic Russians I know all about the massacre carried out by the pro Kremlin president who broke on his election manifesto of applying for EU membership at literally the 11th hour under the command of his puppet master Putin who consequently was removed from office by a massive majori ...[text shortened]... yond me given that you supported the removal of a duly elected POTUS by the peoples representatives.
Talk about fairy tales .....................

The elected President was illegally removed while the relevant government buildings were under the control of armed radical nationalists. It was within his legitimate Constitutional power to make economic agreements with whatever country he saw fit; if the People were dissatisfied with that decision the remedy was the next election.


@no1marauder said
Talk about fairy tales .....................

The elected President was illegally removed while the relevant government buildings were under the control of armed radical nationalists. It was within his legitimate Constitutional power to make economic agreements with whatever country he saw fit; if the People were dissatisfied with that decision the remedy was the next election.
He left the country and fled back to his master in the Kremlin at which point the parliament voted him out of office.
Talk about fairy tales you love em.

1 edit

@kevcvs57 said
He left the country and fled back to his master in the Kremlin at which point the parliament voted him out of office.
Talk about fairy tales you love em.
The Parliament had no power to do so as you well know.

It was an armed coup, not a Constitutional transfer of power.

Vote Up
Vote Down

It would seem that the Ukraine fighters (and maybe all fighters) prefer basing where there is a building infrastructure,
and quick and easy access to medicine, food, electricity etc.

1 edit

@vivify said
What made both Iraq and Afghanistan difficult were the resistance forces blending in with civilians putting the U.S. in a position where they had to rethink attacks, lest they kill civilians. Until the U.S. said "fck it" and started killing civilians.

I wonder if Ukraine is hoping to use similar tactics to make Russia look bad when they kill civilians as a propaganda too ...[text shortened]... salt" after they were bombed. Seems you two may have been on to something.

Either way, not good.
.........Vietnam....same thing

1 edit

@no1marauder said
The Parliament had no power to do so as you well know.

It was an armed coup, not a Constitutional transfer of power.
The Parliament where the representatives of the people had no power to oust a president blatantly colluding with a foreign power to the detriment of the people? Are you sure?


@kevcvs57 said
The Parliament where the representatives of the people had no power to oust a president blatantly colluding with a foreign power to the detriment of the people? Are you sure?
Yes, I am sure and I've posted the relevant provisions of the Ukrainian Constitution on this board numerous times. Any impeachment had to be sent first to the Constitutional Court and it never was because that Court wouldn't have accepted such a false charge (Parliament disbanded that Court weeks after the coup). Many of the "People's Representatives" were absent because they feared for their lives because of armed radicals who occupied the government buildings in the capital.

But you know all this, but to you the end of forcing out an elected President who wasn't as amenable to Western domination as you would prefer justified such an illegal act.


@kevcvs57 said
Link please
https://www.washingtontimes.com/sponsored/us-strategy-ukraine-must-include-minority-rights/

To counteract Russian influence in eastern Ukraine, the Ukrainian government radically changed its minority policy. While these measures primarily target the Russian-speaking population in eastern Ukraine, the radical restrictions on native language use have devastated other ethnic groups, too.

• Since 2017, new laws on education and the state language severely restrict ethnic minorities in using and studying in their native language.
• As of July 1, 2021, a new law limits the definition of ‘indigenous’ minorities.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
Ukraine's oppression of ethnic Russians was not carried out by "pro Moscow forces".
True - it wasn't carried out at all.

Unlike Russia's (it's too late now to limit the blame to Putin) bombing of hospitals and schools.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said
The victims of aggression are not absolved of their responsibility to conduct their operations by the rules of war.
"If she didn't want to be raped, she shouldn't have hit him back."

You are disgusting beyond belief.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@shallow-blue said
True - it wasn't carried out at all.

Unlike Russia's (it's too late now to limit the blame to Putin) bombing of hospitals and schools.
You misunderstand me. In no way am I implying that Ukraine's oppression of minority groups were anywhere near what Russia is doing. All I'm saying is that oppression existed.

Maybe "oppression" was too strong of a word, since a lot of implications come with it. It was more systemic discrimination rather than physical violence like what Russia is doing, which is obviously far worse.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@shavixmir said
https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2022/08/ukraine-ukrainian-fighting-tactics-endanger-civilians/

Well, that’s not gonna sit well with the powers that be…
Second Rule of Fight Club: Only the enemy is capable of war crimes.

This axiom probably dates back to 孫子兵法.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify
Perhaps you remember what RUSSIA did to Ukraine in 2014?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@kevcvs57 said
I was asking for a link to the claim by vivify concerning the Ukrainian forces treatment of ethnic Russians
My original point was the Ukraine has a history of mistreating citizens; Russian-speaking Ukrainians are not the only ones:

https://news.un.org/en/story/2018/07/1015022

UN experts urge Ukraine to stop ‘systematic persecution’ of Roma minority

Vote Up
Vote Down

@sonhouse said
@vivify
Perhaps you remember what RUSSIA did to Ukraine in 2014?
Yes, fck Russia. But see my post just above yours.