Go back
An interesting question in today’s ….. New World??

An interesting question in today’s ….. New World??

Debates


@AverageJoe1 said
This makes no sense. So, government is a non-entity? I picture mobs in the street when yousaythat.
You make no sense. You are sue Ann.
And you are Donald Trump. So who's the worst human? I think we know.

1 edit

@Rajk999 said
But ... the story continues in the next few verses with Ananias and Sapphira who lied and said they sold all that they had, when in fact they did not. They were killed by the Holy Spirit.

So the story has far more to it than just being socialist. They were all believers in God, and baptised into Christ by the Holy Spirit, and they were commanded to live righteously, otherwise death could have been the end result.
How does this change anything?

We are still to follow Jesus' teachings.

1 edit

@AverageJoe1 said
Yes, but my revered grandmother replies with this:

There is an important qualification. The early Christians were not commanded by the apostles to abolish private property or surrender all possessions to the state. In fact, Peter’s confrontation with Ananias makes that particularly clear:

“Didn’t it belong to you before it was sold? And after it was sold, wasn’t the ...[text shortened]...

So there you have it Granny says ‘In Your Face’

You are so out there, guard your cred, man.
Hypocrites like you often use the strict wording of the Bible to validate their inhuman treatment of others.

We are warned against doing this, but as usual, you never listen.


@AverageJoe1 said
Robert deNero made 2 movies in 3 1/2 years ..netting him $1B. When he wraps up speaking with Springsteen, singing in a very costly stadium built by a billionaire, where he sells tickets at $500 apiece, the two of them can be those who “ give what they have to give!!!!!! “””

Y’all are pitiful.

I saw some clips of that convention going on at this moment, they ...[text shortened]... ty and dressed like street urchins. Flip over to one of Trump‘s rallies and see some fire Americans.
Pathetically clueless.


@AverageJoe1 said
This makes no sense. So, government is a non-entity? I picture mobs in the street when yousaythat.
You make no sense. You are sue Ann.
The community as a whole makes decisions including government, that is run the by the people.


@Rajk999 said
But ... the story continues in the next few verses with Ananias and Sapphira who lied and said they sold all that they had, when in fact they did not. They were killed by the Holy Spirit.

So the story has far more to it than just being socialist. They were all believers in God, and baptised into Christ by the Holy Spirit, and they were commanded to live righteously, otherwise death could have been the end result.
Indeed they were smitten, but not for giving to the community, but for being hypocrites (saying everybody the gave all the money, when they didn't. Actually from that piece of scripture it is clear that no one is forced to give up their money. But if they claim that they do it needs to be true.


@Suzianne said
I take it that you do not believe in Natural Rights, yet you somehow say you believe in the Constitution. Have you actually read the Declaration of Independence?
? I would think you’d had an interesting response to this question. But you write instead about Natural Rights.
So no answer to the question? Nothing?


Couple of weeks since he last asked this question, got a bunch of answers, let the thread die, and then made an identical one.

Should we bookmark this one and then link to it the next time he starts the exact same thread?


@Suzianne said
How does this change anything?

We are still to follow Jesus' teachings.
Well, surely there is SOME teaching by Jesus. My wife is typing this, I am not so knowledgeable of the Bible, more Catechism.

I Joe) don’t think the Christian teaching is simply “give away what you have\.” Scripture also places a very strong emphasis on working, producing, providing for your own household, and using your abilities productively.

Paul actually makes the connection explicit: he said “Let him labor, working with his hands what is good, that he may have something to give him who has need.

That’s a very different principle from saying that personal achievement, self\-reliance, or building something of your own is somehow contrary to Christianity. The biblical is to produce before you distribute, provide before you depend, and use the fruits of your labor generously when others genuinely need help.

Christian charity and productive selfreliance aren’t opposites. In Scripture, the first can actually depend upon the second. I cannot see why this is a debate with Bible scholars. Mom.


@AverageJoe1
Thankyou. Let us imagine KingDavid throwing this back.


@Suzianne said
Hypocrites like you often use the strict wording of the Bible to validate their inhuman treatment of others.

We are warned against doing this, but as usual, you never listen.
There is nothing hypocritical here, little feller. Save that word for when your dear leaders turn their heads when illegal alien immigrants kill and rape, while trying to close prisons at the same time.
Pitiful.
I guess ‘Pitiful’ is my 2nd-favorite word right behind ‘ Choice’.


@Suzianne said
Pathetically clueless.
Really? Just look at the crowd standing all around Al Sayed, and AOC and Burning Bernie when they are speaking. Then look at the crowd standing behind Trump when he is speaking.. and note that we always have to look at Gavin Newson’s hairless chest with two open buttons……we have never seen Donald Trump‘s chest. He wears respectable clothing.
Ha. Now there is a word that liberals have never typed on the Forum. Respectable..


@Ponderable said
Indeed they were smitten, but not for giving to the community, but for being hypocrites (saying everybody the gave all the money, when they didn't. Actually from that piece of scripture it is clear that no one is forced to give up their money. But if they claim that they do it needs to be true.
Sue (clueless poster above) would say that those biblical wretches were (her favorite word) hypocrites .
Another long day for Susan


@AverageJoe1 said
Sue (clueless poster above) would say that those biblical wretches were (her favorite word) hypocrites .
Another long day for Susan
She would be right, not clueless.


@Ponderable said
Indeed they were smitten, but not for giving to the community, but for being hypocrites (saying everybody the gave all the money, when they didn't. Actually from that piece of scripture it is clear that no one is forced to give up their money. But if they claim that they do it needs to be true.
Is there a point here, or are you just repeating what I already said?