Another trans "girl" wins two state championships

@wildgrass said
Your posts are incoherent Mike. We haven't needed chromosome testing in sports for 30 years And it's been fine outside of a few very rare exceptions.

The issue has returned to the forefront because politicians needed an issue to prop up a fascist government.

@mike69 said
How stupid can you get. How long has the delivering doctor looked at the genitalia and decided gender of the baby at birth from predetermined standards already in place? Was this only a conservative viewpoint or the standard. What does this have to do with me or anything I’ve said here. I would imagine even a caveman and woman knew the difference and what decided it. I wa ...[text shortened]... ng with a trans woman is disgusting and you wouldn’t do it, If their a real woman why not fuktard???

@no1marauder said
Fine, I'll make a deal:

You right wingers stop making a thread every time a transgender woman competes in, say, a badminton tournament and I'll stop eviscerating your pathetic arguments which always come down to "It's a dude"!

OK with you?

@Mott-The-Hoople said
AKA…birth defects

@AverageJoe1 said
Marauder, et al, want us to stop the world and change it, by applying these minuscule people as, what, catalyst for societal modifications??
The logic of one of you libs saing there are 'only 200' men trying to beat women in sports.
Hey, Sonhouse, news flash.......In each race are about 8 women (1600 women total) to get beat and lose out on scholarships.
So, ...[text shortened]... Well, it is Only 1600, AverageJoe. Why, Joe there is a girl out there who can jump 18.3 feet!!!!

@mike69 said
How stupid can you get. How long has the delivering doctor looked at the genitalia and decided gender of the baby at birth from predetermined standards already in place? Was this only a conservative viewpoint or the standard. What does this have to do with me or anything I’ve said here. I would imagine even a caveman and woman knew the difference and what decided it. I wa ...[text shortened]... ng with a trans woman is disgusting and you wouldn’t do it, If their a real woman why not fuktard???

@no1marauder said
The whole exercise is pointless if you refuse to recognize that people can and do change sex and that surgical means to do so have existed for almost a hundred years. Will you accept that reality?

@AThousandYoung said
Nobody is born a woman.

@AverageJoe1 said
Let us first see this, since you limit your remark to 'sex'.

"either of the two main categories (male and female) into which humans and most other living things are divided on the basis of their reproductive functions."
"adults of both sexes"

You would do us, and yourself maybe, a great service if you could apply what you just said to the above definition of Sex.

@no1marauder said
So you won't accept reality.

Fine.

Defining sex by reproductive capabilities would mean many people would have none.

@Mott-The-Hoople said
Why have different divisions in sports?
Let just have baseball, men, women, confused all on the same team, football, basketball, tennis, all sports

@Mott-The-Hoople said
Why have different divisions in sports?
Let just have baseball, men, women, confused all on the same team, football, basketball, tennis, all sports

@AverageJoe1 said
Marauder as usual attempts to muddle up a very, very, very simple question. All of my questions have been simple. His response to you (ATY response) is more than I can stand. But he does not answer my question just above, about applying his logic of changing your body one way or another, to the definition of sex. Why does he not just directly answer that question?
I ...[text shortened]... changing sex? That is why I thought I would define the word sex first, the word he used.
Alas….

I am saying that about eight clicks back marauder says that people change sex. I am asking him to give us the definitive explanation of what he means when he says that. I could put it a lot of different ways, like if I remove my wewee, would that change my sex. After he answers that question which he will not, I would then say, and he will hate this, what if I am in a car wreck and my genitals are totally torn off of my body. Has my sex changed????
?????????
I want him to answer questions real simple and he will not do it.

@no1marauder said
ATY already answered that question and I agree with his assessment. "Competitive balance".