Go back
Ethnic cleansing without genocide?

Ethnic cleansing without genocide?

Debates


Kamala says Israel is not committing genocide in Gaza.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/harris-campaign-says-she-did-not-agree-with-protester-accusing-israel-of-genocide/

But Israeli ministers are calling for the ethnic cleansing of Gaza.

https://news.antiwar.com/2024/10/21/israeli-ministers-call-for-expulsion-of-palestinians-at-resettle-gaza-conference/?fbclid=IwY2xjawGFST5leHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHZn0STcys4B1nfMkXQv49_Yp6cav0ATym9DO7ltkc2Qn2rjokY7KTE9-ng_aem_8iTs4_OEAA4JPxoun0elTA#gsc.tab=0

https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/[WORD TOO LONG]

Can Israel ethically cleanse Gaza without committing genocide?

https://www.britannica.com/topic/genocide

I don't think so. Kamala deserves a fact check for being a liar liar pants on fire.
She is pretending Israel is not being genocidal and being open about it. Israeli ministers are calling for genocide.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Metal-Brain said
Kamala says Israel is not committing genocide in Gaza.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/harris-campaign-says-she-did-not-agree-with-protester-accusing-israel-of-genocide/

But Israeli ministers are calling for the ethnic cleansing of Gaza.

https://news.antiwar.com/2024/10/21/israeli-ministers-call-for-expulsion-of-palestinians-at-resettle-gaza-conference/?fbclid=IwY2 ...[text shortened]... g Israel is not being genocidal and being open about it. Israeli ministers are calling for genocide.
I disagree with Kamala. Israel is literally murdering tens of thousands of civilians.

However, you can ethnically cleanse an area without genocide (think mass deportations, a provoked exodus, etc. ).

1 edit

@shavixmir said
I disagree with Kamala. Israel is literally murdering tens of thousands of civilians.

However, you can ethnically cleanse an area without genocide (think mass deportations, a provoked exodus, etc. ).
It depends on the interpretation of the word "destruction". You said Israel is literally murdering tens of thousands of civilians. How many have to die to consider it destruction?

Genocide, the deliberate and systematic destruction of a group of people because of their ethnicity, nationality, religion, or race.

https://www.britannica.com/topic/genocide

Israel is not herding them up to relocate them. They are systematically killing civilians in an attempt to motivate them to leave on their own. Then they lie by claiming every kitchen has a missile in it to justify killing civilians.

https://grabien.com/file?id=2617598

If people are stupid enough to buy that then Bill Gates has a missile in his kitchen. Bomb him with a drone.


@Metal-Brain said
It depends on the interpretation of the word "destruction". You said Israel is literally murdering tens of thousands of civilians. How many have to die to consider it destruction?

Genocide, the deliberate and systematic destruction of a group of people because of their ethnicity, nationality, religion, or race.

https://www.britannica.com/topic/genocide
Did you even read what I posted?

There is a chance that Israel’s behaviour in Palestine will be judged a genocide. That will greatly depend on the eventual outcome.

Israel is ethnically cleansing Palestinian land. They’ve been doing that since the 40’s.

Ethnic cleansing does not have to be a genocide.


@shavixmir said
Did you even read what I posted?

There is a chance that Israel’s behaviour in Palestine will be judged a genocide. That will greatly depend on the eventual outcome.

Israel is ethnically cleansing Palestinian land. They’ve been doing that since the 40’s.

Ethnic cleansing does not have to be a genocide.
Israel is not herding them up to relocate them. They are systematically killing civilians in an attempt to motivate them to leave on their own. Then they lie by claiming every kitchen has a missile in it to justify killing civilians.

https://grabien.com/file?id=2617598

If people are stupid enough to buy that then Bill Gates has a missile in his kitchen. Bomb him with a drone.


@shavixmir
Israel wants to bomb more hospitals.

https://thecradle.co/articles/media-tour-of-beirut-hospital-disproves-israeli-claim-of-hezbollah-bunker

If I claimed bad guys had a bunker under a hospital and bombed it would I be the good guy? This is insane.


@Metal-Brain said
Israel is not herding them up to relocate them. They are systematically killing civilians in an attempt to motivate them to leave on their own. Then they lie by claiming every kitchen has a missile in it to justify killing civilians.

https://grabien.com/file?id=2617598

If people are stupid enough to buy that then Bill Gates has a missile in his kitchen. Bomb him with a drone.
Are you arguing with yourself on this one?


@shavixmir
From the link below:

"Many experts agree that fascism is a mass political movement that emphasizes extreme nationalism, militarism, and the supremacy of the nation over the individual."

https://education.cfr.org/learn/reading/what-fascism

Israel is by definition a fascist country.


@Metal-Brain said
Israel is not herding them up to relocate them. They are systematically killing civilians in an attempt to motivate them to leave on their own. Then they lie by claiming every kitchen has a missile in it to justify killing civilians.

https://grabien.com/file?id=2617598

If people are stupid enough to buy that then Bill Gates has a missile in his kitchen. Bomb him with a drone.
Stop spamming the forum.

You already posted that.


@Metal-Brain said
Kamala says Israel is not committing genocide in Gaza.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/harris-campaign-says-she-did-not-agree-with-protester-accusing-israel-of-genocide/

But Israeli ministers are calling for the ethnic cleansing of Gaza.

https://news.antiwar.com/2024/10/21/israeli-ministers-call-for-expulsion-of-palestinians-at-resettle-gaza-conference/?fbclid=IwY2 ...[text shortened]... g Israel is not being genocidal and being open about it. Israeli ministers are calling for genocide.
Genocide of the Jews is the stated goal of the Palestinians. Israel has no interest in killling Palestinians, and proof of that is the there are over 2 million Arabs living in Israel peacefully. Israel's aim is the eliminate the threat of terrorism. People who want Israel to fail, and who support Islamic extremism, foolishly label Israel's actions as genocide.


@Rajk999 said
Genocide of the Jews is the stated goal of the Palestinians. Israel has no interest in killling Palestinians, and proof of that is the there are over 2 million Arabs living in Israel peacefully. Israel's aim is the eliminate the threat of terrorism. People who want Israel to fail, and who support Islamic extremism, foolishly label Israel's actions as genocide.
You have a remarkable ability to look at facts and summarise them in an illogical way.
You're unique.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@yo-its-me said
You have a remarkable ability to look at facts and summarise them in an illogical way.
You're unique.
Your remarkable ability is waffle, ie write without making your point clearly. Maybe you can tell me what it is I wrote that is illogical.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Rajk999 said
Your remarkable ability is waffle, ie write without making your point clearly. Maybe you can tell me what it is I wrote that is illogical.
To do that, I would have to guess at where you are coming from.
Why do you think that genocide of the Jews is the stated goal of the Palestinians?
Are you saying there are 2 million Levantine Arabs living in Israel carefree?
What is foolish about summarising mass murder of a particular race as genocide? And why would that equate to wanting Israel to fail, or wanting to support Islamic extremism? Can't we agree the war is unnecessary?

Vote Up
Vote Down


@yo-its-me said

Why do you think that genocide of the Jews is the stated goal of the Palestinians?
Can't we agree the war is unnecessary?
You really need to get your facts in order.
Genocide of the Jews is in their charter.
Genocide of the Jews is taught in their schools to kids
Genocide of the Jews is prayed for in the mosques
Genocide of the Jews is spoken of in their homes
Genocide of the Jews is the reason for billions of $$$ spent on tunnels
Genocide of the Jews is the reason why all hospitals, schools and civilian buildins have military hardward

Yes this war is absolutely necessary because Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran all want the Jews dead.