Go back
Mention of GameKnot...

Mention of GameKnot...

General

Vote Up
Vote Down

...is enough to get a thread closed now?

We really are stepping back into the dark ages. Last year, Russ said that he'd only close a thread about another chess site if it was blatant advertising by a brand new player. What's changed?

D

Vote Up
Vote Down

I probably said I would not remove them (as they would on many sites) but obviously I am not too comfortable with a site name sat in a thread title like this.

-Russ

Vote Up
Vote Down

I think Ragnorak is still having difficulty understanding that this is not a democracy.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by hopscotch
I think Ragnorak is still having difficulty understanding that this is not a democracy.
Well neither is Morocco but they do know other countries exist.

edited for the slow people among us.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nyxie
Well neither is maracco but they do know other countries exist.
What's maracco?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by hopscotch
What's maracco?
A country outside of rhp.

Your statement really relates to ragnorak's question even less then mine, so maybe you should try correcting yourself first.

Vote Up
Vote Down

The reality is, they are competing sites. People flow back and forth from both all the time. But, because of the financial risks I undertake in keeping this site going, I naturally would prefer it to be one way and not the other. 🙂 I do not perceive closing a thread to be heavy handed in this instance.

-Russ

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by hopscotch
I think Ragnorak is still having difficulty understanding that this is not a democracy.
Dated: 22nd August
From: http://www.timeforchess.com/board/showthread.php?threadid=27838&page=10
Ragnorak: "I always think of it as a benevolent dictatorship."

What I might be having difficulty understanding now is whether it is a benevolent dictatorship or a plain aul despotic one.

D

Vote Up
Vote Down

i used to play there and here, then decided that i didn't like the way the site was being run (closing of the forums, only one user from each computer etc) so i quite. i started a game a while back there, but the interface is kinda slow and i kept on forgetting to move. plus, i'm a pawn star here. oh so much cheaper!

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nyxie
A country outside of rhp.

Your statement really relates to ragnorak's question even less then mine, so maybe you should try correcting yourself first.
(Morroco)

By critising the closing of a thread Ragnorak is stepping up to have his say as though it mattered, as if he could really have any influence on the governence of this site, therefore he must in some way believe that a democratic process exists.

If you went into a kiteshop and stuck up posters advertising the other kiteshop across town what do you think would happen?

Ragnorak: you're trying to incite some sort of mob riot / consumer uprising over freedom of speech, therefore you're trying to do exactly what you protested of no1marauder.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Reporting for mob duty...where's the food?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by hopscotch
(Morroco)

By critising the closing of a thread Ragnorak is stepping up to have his say as though it mattered, as if he could really have any influence on the governence of this site, therefore he must in some way believe that a democratic process exists.

If you went into a kiteshop and stuck up posters advertising the other kiteshop across town what ...[text shortened]... ver freedom of speech, therefore you're trying to do exactly what you protested of no1marauder.
People are aware of both sites. The free exchange of information could only lead to a better understanding. Rhp is better then gameknot in almost all regards excepting one and that is conditional moves.

Your anology is wrong because dustn was'nt advertising for anyone to go and pay money at the other site, he was just mentioning it. He did'nt tell anyone to cancel their subscription here and transfer to gameknot. So no there was no poster in a window here.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nyxie
People are aware of both sites. The free exchange of information could only lead to a better understanding. Rhp is better then gameknot in almost all regards excepting one and that is conditional moves.

Your anology is wrong because dustn was'nt advertising for anyone to go and pay money at the other site, he was just mentioning it. He did'nt tell anyone ...[text shortened]... el their subscription here and transfer to gameknot. So no there was no poster in a window here.
Gameknot has conditional moves!
Hmmm..

Vote Up
Vote Down

well I joined gameknot 2 days ago, and as far as I can see it's crap. I can't see any way of reviewing message logs, the main forum is closed, I can't send any PMs, instead only reply to ones sent to me, and the subscription is... well, either pricey or nonsense "privileges". Not that I was really considering subscribing there, I just checked out of interest. Only thing that's really better imho is that you can join features like the clans on rhp without subscribing. I haven't tried it though, and I'm not about to.
Ummm yeah that's my 2 cents.

Oh yeah, plus we have the wonderful clan forums here 😀

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by hopscotch
I think Ragnorak is still having difficulty understanding that this is not a democracy.
Well, the thread is back. I doubt it would be back if Ragnorak hadn't said anything. The fact that this is not a democracy doesn't mean you shouldn't say if you dislike the decisions which are made, or that nothing will change if you do so.