03 Feb '07 18:18>
Originally posted by wormwoodWhich critique?
how do you ever expect to get any better if a mere thought of critique gets you all defensive?
Critics come in more than one form. Some are constructive. Others are counter productive.
Remarks in a thread such as this, resembling 'your chess is rather primitive' is unneeded criticism, along with others.
It really makes the commenter look rather bitter towards the person.
Someone rated at 2400 may indeed feel that someone rated at 2100 has a rather primitive understanding as well. More than likely they have more class than to enter a thread of appreciation for said person and point that out.
My mother always said if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all. Would seem to fit for a thread of this nature.
Rahim didn't even bother commenting in the thread, 'tooting' his own horn as some have said, until one poster falsely stated how he achieved his rating.
So we have false statements and somewhat disparaging comments from the critics.
I certainly do not plan on getting any better listening to critique of that nature.