05 May '08 18:44>
Originally posted by PhlabibitSorry, but I don't see how my proposal [in its current form, not the original version] takes anything away from individual players. [They would still be allowed to play out their clan games. They would still get those games rated. They would still get personal stats updated.] The only thing it takes away is points from the clan that would otherwise profit from the wins/draws of a non-clan member.
The clan score system stunk from day one, everything else is just glaze on the bundt cake. If this is a problem, I like the idea of Active players needing to finish active games before new members can start... but that raises another problem when someone has to leave a clan for a good reason.
Just like trying to 'fix' the vacation system... you're taking good things away from players who are not trying to 'abuse' the system.
P-
I have been trying to work with people and refine the proposal to best address the problem of clan rotation without unduly harming the individual player. The problem is that everyone seems to be reading only the very first post in the thread. 😞