27 Nov '06 22:24>
Originally posted by RagnorakI agree with this in theory .. I am in 2 tournaments well below my current rating, but i joined them when i was just out of provisional rating (my initial 20 odd games were against a friend of mine that was just learning and provisional too). The problem is i don't think ratings settle in until you've played 200 odd games against a variety of opponents. I would love to gracefully withdraw from the tournament 1200-1450 but there is no option. I think most people in my situation would do the right thing if given the chance. After all who wants a tournament win against 1200's when you are rated 1800+? There probably is no magic formula for this. I think tournament mods are a good idea, then we can sort these things out with a little individual discretion. A community site has the advantage of being able to solve problems using its greatest asset .. the community.
Read this post, and the next 7...
http://www.timeforchess.com/board/showthread.php?threadid=46202&page=2#post_828738
I don't agree that most of the people that "abuse" (whether purposely or not) the banded tournaments are people who leave for a while. Me and fckallie ended up competing in the final of a rookie tournament when we first joined. I didn't ...[text shortened]... ional players from banded tournaments, which Russ implemented within about 10 minutes.
D