Originally posted by LemonJello
The fact that so many of your metaphysical commitments hinge critically on the existence of some 2000 year-old zombie water-walker,
Sounds like rather hysterical lashing out. When I hear the word "zombie" I think of a horror movie. Do the Gospels read like a horror movie to you ?
When I think of "zombie" I think of a corpse walking showing marked signs of lack of self control, I think Jesus demonstrated enough self control over His own being which causes you to appear as a zombie in comparison.
Compared to Jesus, you live much more like a walking corpse under some voodoo spell. I think Jesus displayed far more self control then you ever will.
born of a virgin, father of himself, sacrificer of himself unto himself to appease himself, isn't our problem, either.
While you scoff, I don't see any explanation of how Jesus could orchestrate the surroundings of His own birth in accordance with a prophecy given during MIcah's lifetime six hundred years previous. The experts of the Hebrew Scriptures during the time of Christ's birth pinpointing the place of the birth of such a Person based on words penned by the prophet Micah (737 - 696 BC).
I think we're dealing with Someone not only whose life is eternal duration wise, but is also infinite in quality and also transcendence over time. Our reaction to such a Person might be compared to beings living on a two dimensional plane who encounter a being of three dimensions.
All this about a Father to Himself, to sacrifice to Himself to appease Himself expresses your bafflement and cynicism. My reactions are different. I think we are encountering an eternal life which to our limitations confounds our limits of rationality.
Of course if Jesus had just done a "trick" of walking on water, I don't think you would display the vehemence and disdain in your tone. It is not walking on water that bothers you, I think. I think there is something in His teaching and words which is the greater irritation, even perhaps fear.
I think some people should ask themselves honestly "Why do I have contempt for Jesus, really?" Magicians like Houdini don't cause such words of contempt, like calling
"The Prince of Peace" to many, a "zombie".
Anyway, the stench of spiritual death is more pronounced in people who do not have self control over their sinning nature. The slaves to transgressions and iniquity are far
more like walking dead men then such a Person as Jesus. He expressed the highest level of morality known in human history.
Compared to Christ are you sure you're not the zombie ?
I take those to be problems specific and peculiar to a worldview like yours.
I take God's triune being to be a instance of divine nature that us, bound by time and the limited dimensions of creation, to be perplexed at when we encounter time's Creator.
It is understandable that there might be something nearly incomprehensible to our creation bound minds when the Greater Cause of time and space reaches into our world for our salvation.
I realize some will say "This looks like God sacrificing Himself to Himself". But I think probably the matter
"God is love" may indicate a profoundness in God's being which will take eternity to explore.
If [b]"God is love"{/b] describes God even before the existence of the universe there must be something about God that appears too extraordinary for our creaturehood.
I don't react to the mystery with same attitude because I don't just select one or two events of Christ's life. I holistically consider the fuller scope of His words and deeds. To me He is not just another Harry Houdini.
I guess another worry is in extrapolating from an explanative role to one of necessity.
I am not sure I am "extrapolating from a explanative [sic] role to one of necessity." But go on.
That God has such a far-reaching role in explaining, to your own satisfaction, your own metaphysical commitments does not somehow make God necessary in such roles. This, again, I take to be related to a failure of perspective-taking.
I cannot long discuss this at the moment. But that our moral being is only material movement of chemicals and molecules doesn't make sense to me.
I see our humanity as an effect which is due to a cause which is greater. My sense of justice, rightness, fairness, ethics, morality should not be due to something on a lower level of life, like an energy or force. It should be due to Someone of a higher level of life than myself.
Some people may refer to a "Higher Power". But power needs a generator. A personless "higher power" I would take to be on a lower level of being than myself.
Electricity is a great power. But I consider electricity to be on a lower level of being than my consciousness and certainly my moral awareness. I think the source of these attributes must be not just a "power". for I am "higher" than any power.
Something like a moral being on a higher level of being I would take as the source.
You spoke of my quoting the Bible. I do that because I believe that God has spoken to man. Even more this speaking God has become a man, the One you call a zombie.
I think you'r calling Christ a zombie is not a statement on how much of an enigma Christ is as much as how low humans have fallen from a normality at which we were designed to live originally.
That a man should be so utterly one with God, I take as normal. It is we and the world we produce which has fallen far below normal.
Jesus was not only good. He was good in a glorious way. He was not just right. He was right with splendor and radiance making a cataclysmic impact on human history.
I would dare say that any given three and one half years of your life in comparison would make you look like the stumbling zombie.
To be clear, I would have no problems with the belief that God grounds (or is necessary for grounding) morality or meaning or whatever, inasmuch as the belief is based on good reasons.
I might entertain that a materialist view of the universe is the answer if you could prove that a "good" atom and a "bad" atom exists.
[quote]
Similarly, I would have no problems with the claim that God is necessary for grounding matters of high existential seriousness, inasmuch as the claim is tied to good justificatory considerations. {/quote]
I may have a comment latter.
This is sonship on a relative's home PC.