Originally posted by knightmeister
But the point is that at the point in time t=0 there is no time , so how does time begin ? How does the beginning of time occur if there is not time for it to begin in?
Sure , time exists between points t=0 and t=0.00000000000001 but by then time has already begun. My point is - how does t=0 get to t=0.00001 in the first place?
If change can only occur in time then how did that change come about since t=0?
This is an odd variation on the various paradoxes posed by Zeno.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeno%27s_paradoxes
If I am taking a journey, what is the first distance that I traverse? A step? Well, a step can be
divided into a half step. 1/2 step then? Well, that, too, can be divided. And so on. Therefore,
I can never take the journey because I can never initiate it. Therefore the journey is illusory.
Before you existed, there existed no 't' for you. As soon as you were conceived (just to avoid
argument), t=0 for you. That is, for your frame of reference, t=0 at conception is a reasonable
assignment. There's no reason to disbelieve the existence of t=-1, or t=-10 or t=-1x10^13857,
but it's all supposition and inference.
If we are taking, as the frame of reference, the Universe, then t=0 at the Big Bang. Doing so
doesn't mean that there isn't t=-1, &c. But because of the event of the Big Bang, we can't but
speculate about what t=-1 might be. There might be no events preceding t=0, but because we
can measure events afterward, we can extrapolate the passage of time before the first event
we decide to assign to t=0.
Nemesio