Originally posted by EcstremeVenom
you have to show somebody evil and good to give them free will, you can not just show them good; they would have no choice to be good because they would not know of evil, and that is not free will.
But they did not know about good and evil until they ate from the tree. God forbade them to eat from the tree and learn of good and evil. That is why they were punished.
Genisis 3:22 Then the Lord God said, "Behold, the man has become like one of us, knowing good and evil; and now, lest he put forth his hand and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever" –23 therefore the Lord God sent him forth from the garden of Eden...
So, by your reasoning, if knowledge of good and evil is a prerequisite for free will, then it's a Catch 22. God wants them to have freewill, but he forbids them to take the step that enables it...
According to the story, when god made Adam from the dust of the ground and breathed life into his nostrils, he foresaw already that Adam would eat from the tree, and he knew the exact second he would do so. It is not possible to "surprise" an omniscient being. But god created Adam anyway, knowing full well what would happen. If god wanted a different result, he could have used a slightly different dust/breath ratio to achieve a more favorable result. The fact that god went with that particular version of Adam, out of all the possible versions of Adam, indicates that that is exactly what god wanted all along. He knew that the chain of events he set in motion, beginning with the creation of Adam, would culminate in the eating of the apple. He could have tweaked those starting conditions to achieve any eventual result he desired, but he went with that particular version because THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT HE WANTED. Mankind was meant to fail from the very start. It was a setup from the beginning. Every result that comes about is necessarily the result that god wants. It is not possible for any result to come about that is contrary to god's will.