10 May '06 07:30>
Originally posted by dottewellIf someone says "this tree is green" they are referring to a scientific property of that tree which can be proved correct . Beauty cannot be measured scientifically . You can say "this painting is made of oil and canvas" but there is no essential quality of the painting that makes it a 'fact' that the painting is beautiful. One could equally say that the painting is ugly and there is nothing in the property of the painting to dispute it. If I say "this tree is blue" I can be shown to be wrong. You have made an error of context here. You cannot begin to prove that a painting is beautiful unless you believe that beauty is something more than a human concept , but if you do that then you are on the way to saying something very radically different from what most Atheists believe.
Don't get carried away with the "built in" thing; it was just a suggested way of thinking about it. Certainly wasn't meant to imply there was anything doing the building.
Let me explain another way. It may be true that our language and concepts have developed for some evolutionary reason; I don't know. But, given the language we have, when someone utter ...[text shortened]... reference to the particles in my brain. They are outward-directed, not inward-directed.