Originally posted by Suzianne
Is this also why some atheists take offense at Christians saying "Well, that's your choice", or is that another topic entirely?
It's another topic.
Look, I can choose whether or not I worship something, worshipping is
something I consciously do or do not do.
Belief on the other hand, isn't something that can simply be chosen.
I can't just will myself to believe the Earth is flat.
I can't just will myself to think I can fly.
And I can't just will myself to believe in gods.
That's not to say I am incapable of believing in gods, just that I need to
be presented with evidence sufficient to make me believe.
How we form beliefs is a tricky subject, but they are not formed by any simple
version of choice.
Now someone has evidently convinced you that belief based on faith is not just
ok but is something to be applauded and valued.
And so you believe [some] things on faith.
I am convinced that you can only believe things based on rationality and evidence.
As such I believe things that have evidence enough to support them.
If the evidence changes, so do my beliefs.
And in some cases where there is insufficient evidence I don't have beliefs.
As an example I don't have a belief as to whether a historical JC existed or not.
I do have a belief that it's more probable he didn't, but it's no slam dunk either way,
and so I don't have a belief that JC did or did not exist as a historical figure.
And I didn't go out and choose to believe that, I read some works that made a compelling
argument backed up by evidence and that changed my mind.
Belief isn't a simple choice.
And saying that it is belittles it for believers and atheists alike.