04 Jul 12
Considering the extraordinary complexity of deadly diseases such as AIDS, malaria, the flu, dysentery etc, it seams reasonable to say that if the complexity of life points to intelligent design, then these diseases do too.
So the question then is why were they designed and by whom?
Suffering is usually blamed on Adam or Satan or a combination of both.
So did Satan have a hand in developing some life forms? Is there more than one 'intelligent designer'?
Do you think we can detect their different styles in the genetic code the write? Do you think maybe Satan signs his name on his pieces?
04 Jul 12
Originally posted by twhiteheadSome say HIV and other STDs are used by God to punish sexual immorality. With gods like this, who needs Satan? 😵
Considering the extraordinary complexity of deadly diseases such as AIDS, malaria, the flu, dysentery etc, it seams reasonable to say that if the complexity of life points to intelligent design, then these diseases do too.
So the question then is why were they designed and by whom?
Suffering is usually blamed on Adam or Satan or a combination of both.
...[text shortened]... t styles in the genetic code the write? Do you think maybe Satan signs his name on his pieces?
04 Jul 12
Originally posted by sonhouseWar at least can be directly blamed on man and the argument from freewill is used
If we have such a beneficent god, why would it let hundreds of millions die in wars?
(despite the paradox created by the fact that the dead did not choose to die).
However it is a well known fact that disease kills far more people than wars (even during wars, disease kills more people than guns do (except possibly in very modern wars were medicine has improved).
04 Jul 12
Originally posted by twhiteheadI think the idea is that we're supposed to grow by undergoing and, if possible, overcoming hardship and suffering.
Considering the extraordinary complexity of deadly diseases such as AIDS, malaria, the flu, dysentery etc, it seams reasonable to say that if the complexity of life points to intelligent design, then these diseases do too.
So the question then is why were they designed and by whom?
Suffering is usually blamed on Adam or Satan or a combination of both.
...[text shortened]... t styles in the genetic code the write? Do you think maybe Satan signs his name on his pieces?
04 Jul 12
1 edit
Originally posted by SwissGambit
Some say HIV and other STDs are used by God to punish sexual immorality. With gods like this, who needs Satan? 😵
Some say HIV and other STDs are used by God to punish sexual immorality. With gods like this, who needs Satan?
"And Cain said to Jehovah, My punishment is greater than I can bear." (Gen. 4:13)
Sigh. How about we look at chastizement from God another way. How about considering symptoms which are uncomfortable as a warning in love, for a person to consider their ways.
How about a hangover and splitting headache in the morning cause one to thing "Hmmm. Maybe next time I should be careful how much I indulge in drinking strong alchololic drink."
How about one consider somethings allowed by our Heavenly Father to be a warning light, a yellow light, a caution, a "proceed at your own risk".
I am not being trivial about this. But some things can cause a person to stop and consider their ways before God. Some have time to pray, repent, seek forgiveness, and reconciliation with a God of love.
If you only think "Oh this MEAN God is just punishing me." you are rather like Cain in Genesis. He is not SORRY he is only sorry that he got caught.
So I believe AIDs has caused many a sinner to have time to consider his life and ways before God. (I said some, not all).
Now, I expect that someone will of course jump to the conclusion that everyone who is ill with HIV is being disciplined for sinning by God. And then every calamity of any kind will be considered as God's chastizement. Go ahead. Drive the point into that corner. I know some want to.
That is not my point. My point is that a different heart would think of ailment allowed by God in another attitude. The only way of thinking is not "Damn! I'm being PUNISHED by God the mean one. "
That is not the only angle to view AIDs or HIV from.
- Joined
- 29 Dec 08
- Moves
- 6788
Originally posted by twhiteheadElementary, my dear Watson. We can question either the motivations or the perp or the limitations of the perp, or we can question our perceptive and cognitive ability, and possibly, our own motivation to properly understand and appreciate the evidence.
Considering the extraordinary complexity of deadly diseases such as AIDS, malaria, the flu, dysentery etc, it seams reasonable to say that if the complexity of life points to intelligent design, then these diseases do too.
So the question then is why were they designed and by whom?
Suffering is usually blamed on Adam or Satan or a combination of both.
t styles in the genetic code the write? Do you think maybe Satan signs his name on his pieces?
These are the options in any CSI-like investigation of the scene. Take your pick, choose your side; although that choice is most likely already made going in to the scene.
At least in a CSI-like scenario, there are qualifying requirements of the abilities of the investigators. The only qualifying requirement here, is the ability to tap the keys.
04 Jul 12
To restate my point in case it wasn't clear:
1. Those that promote Intelligent design claim that the complexity of life points to an intelligent designer (and they usually promote the idea of a single specific such intelligent designer).
2. The complexity of diseases suggests that they too must have been intelligently designed. They did not come about via unguided evolution.
3. It is clear that many diseases especially those specific to man cause an enormous amount of suffering and death.
4. Whoever the intelligent designer was presumably not only knew they would cause suffering but specifically designed them to do so. The suffering of man due to disease was planned out by the intelligent designer of those diseases.
So my questions are:
a. Is God the intelligent designer or someone else?
b. If God is the intelligent designer is there some reasonable explanation for his actions?
04 Jul 12
1 edit
Originally posted by SwissGambitSo if you tell your children not to go play in the street they will punish their children for playing out in the street by letting them get hit?
Some say HIV and other STDs are used by God to punish sexual immorality. With gods like this, who needs Satan? 😵
Hmm?
I know, I know, an all powerful God should string us along like puppet and never let this happen.
The fact of the matter is that if people obeyed the sexual mandates in the Bible STD's would not be a problem
- Joined
- 29 Dec 08
- Moves
- 6788
04 Jul 12
Originally posted by twhiteheadI would say, if there is an ID, what can we learn about the designer by looking at the design?
To restate my point in case it wasn't clear:
1. Those that promote Intelligent design claim that the complexity of life points to an intelligent designer (and they usually promote the idea of a single specific such intelligent designer).
2. The complexity of diseases suggests that they too must have been intelligently designed. They did not come about v ...[text shortened]... e?
b. If God is the intelligent designer is there some reasonable explanation for his actions?
But here's the rub: What we see is at least partly our creation, in more ways than one.
04 Jul 12
Originally posted by whodeyA good parent tries to prevent the child from playing in the busy street. He does not get frustrated, start up the car, and run over his own kid.
So if you tell your children not to go play in the street they will punish their children for playing out in the street by letting them get hit?
Hmm?
I know, I know, an all powerful God should string us along like puppet and never let this happen.
The fact of the matter is that if people obeyed the sexual mandates in the Bible STD's would not be a problem
We don't need or want overcompensating mandates to solve the problem. The fundamentalists and paternalists always want to cut down the whole tree because some of the branches wither.
04 Jul 12
Originally posted by jaywillThese same people don't seem to care much about whether the affected people actually change their ways. They seem almost delighted at God's disgust with the 'wicked'.Some say HIV and other STDs are used by God to punish sexual immorality. With gods like this, who needs Satan?
[b]"And Cain said to Jehovah, My punishment is greater than I can bear." (Gen. 4:13)
Sigh. How about we look at chastizement from God another way. How about considering symptoms which are uncomfortable as a warning in ...[text shortened]... ED by God the mean one. "
That is not the only angle to view AIDs or HIV from.[/b]
But maybe you could share your perspective with them the next time you meet one. The idea of prevention/correction would be more palatable than 'punishment as a form of vengeance for defiance of an Authority Figure'.
04 Jul 12
Originally posted by whodeyI can tell by your halfhearted attempt that you don't really buy your own argument. So why do you make it? In the hope others will buy it?
So if you tell your children not to go play in the street they will punish their children for playing out in the street by letting them get hit?
Hmm?
I know, I know, an all powerful God should string us along like puppet and never let this happen.
The fact of the matter is that if people obeyed the sexual mandates in the Bible STD's would not be a problem