Originally posted by The Chess Express
Do you believe that you were given a second chance by God, or that it was entirely the skill of the doctors that saved you?
Aside from renouncing the way that you were taught to believe, what kind of changes have you made in your life as a result of this?
I don’t know the reasons why this happened, but if nothing else it shows that there is ...[text shortened]... e answer. Perhaps you could work on loving him for showing mercy and giving you a second chance.
You know, I would just like to take asp at his word about the “rightness” and sincerity of his former Christian faith. Is that so hard to do? You can go poking around, looking for “where he went wrong,” or where “his faith wasn’t true” and maybe at some point say “Aha! That’s it!”—but that’s kind of a pharisaical approach isn’t it? It seems to be a common perspective that no one can have been a “true Christian” and then change—in good faith and for arguable reasons. If you start with that presumption, then you’re simply dismissing his experiences out of hand.
I just can’t see starting with the assumption that asp
must have in some way failed in his Christian faith—inwardly or outwardly. I personally think it was rather brave of him to post his experience here. I don’t think he give a fig for how we “interpret” it—I think he recognizes that, in a sense, we each have to do that for ourselves, as long as we don’t try to tell him how he must understand it. I think he is also trying to get us to question
ourselves, rather than laying out some “map of where it’s at.” (I say some of this based on his posts elsewhere.)
“I am still seeing what matters.” A candidate for my epitaph…
NOTE to The Chess Express: Yes, it was your post that triggered this one, but neither my post
en toto, nor the use of the second-person “you” is directed at
you. You, I think are simply grappling “out loud” with the content of asp’s post (obviously, you were not dismissing it out of hand). I just don’t want to see it simply degenerate into what I described above.