1 edit
Originally posted by AThousandYoungI want a list of conditions such that upon examing a person's behavior, I can by looking at the conditions determine whether a person has committed sodomy according to your notion of it. I would do this by first ascertaining whether any of the sufficient conditions you list were met by the behavior. If so, I would conclude that we have observed a sodomist in action. Failing that, I would ascertain whether all necessary conditions that you list were met by the behavior. If not, I would conclude that we have not witnessed sodomy.
Do you want a description of acts which are in the poster's opinion sodomy, or do you want a blanket definition of sodomy?
Originally posted by DoctorScribblesMaybe I'm not the right person to ask about this. Sodomy isn't a word I generally use and I would defer to the dictionary if I had to use it.
I want a list of conditions such that upon examing a person's behavior, I can by looking at the conditions determine whether a person has committed sodomy according to your notion of it. I would do this by first ascertaining whether any of the sufficient conditions you list were met by the behavior. If so, I would conclude that we have observed a ...[text shortened]... you list were met by the behavior. If not, I would conclude that we have not witnessed sodomy.
Originally posted by AThousandYoungThe question was stated clearly and it didn't need a whole sentence as an answer. That's why I copy and pasted the question, to be clear.
Because when you wrote 'menstruation' is was somewhat unclear what you meant because you did not write a complete sentence. This is why you were asked 'what about it' I think.
1 edit
Originally posted by shavixmirI, too, found that your respose was ambiguous. I believe that you needed to clarify whether menstruation was a necessary or a sufficient condition for sodomy.
The question was stated clearly and it didn't need a whole sentence as an answer. That's why I copy and pasted the question, to be clear.
Originally posted by DoctorScribblesAlso, does a woman commit sodomy every time she menstruates? Does one commit sodomy when one has intercourse with a menstruating woman? Does one commit sodomy by eating out a menstruating woman? Does a menstruating woman commit sodomy when she blows a guy or eats out a girl? What about having anal sex with a menstruating woman?
I, too, found that your respose was ambiguous. I believe that you needed to clarify whether menstruation was a necessary or a sufficient condition for sodomy.
Originally posted by AThousandYoungand on that note I'm done reading this thread.....
Also, does a woman commit sodomy every time she menstruates? Does one commit sodomy when one has intercourse with a menstruating woman? Does one commit sodomy by eating out a menstruating woman? Does a menstruating woman commit sodomy when she blows a guy or eats out a girl? What about having anal sex with a menstruating woman?
Originally posted by DoctorScribbles
You know the drill by now. Please state in clear language what you believe to be the
1. Necessary conditions, or
2. Sufficient conditions
for committing a sinful act of sodomy.
Cribs, you concerned about whether you committed a sin ? It if hurts like hell, it probably wasn't meant to go there.
Just my 2c.
pc
Originally posted by pcaspianI'm not concerned, I'm just curious. I'm not ashamed to state for the record that I have met more than one of the proposed sufficient criteria for being a sodomite. In my eyes, I have not sinned by doing so.
Cribs, you concerned about whether you committed a sin ? It if hurts like hell, it probably wasn't meant to go there.
Originally posted by AThousandYoungATY still doesn't get it.
Also, does a woman commit sodomy every time she menstruates? Does one commit sodomy when one has intercourse with a menstruating woman? Does one commit sodomy by eating out a menstruating woman? Does a menstruating woman commit sodomy when she blows a guy or eats out a girl? What about having anal sex with a menstruating woman?
*Points and laughs as ATY*
; D