Originally posted by Nemesio
Scott,
Could you please explain how we know something is 50k light years away? I think this is the
stumbling block. That is (and I do not know, otherwise I would offer it), how do we know that
the light that reaches us is 50k years old and not 5k years, say?
Nemesio
Imagine a circular island of radius 10 miles, with a golf cart factory at the center.
Suppose upon arriving at this island, you observe a golf cart at the edge of the island.
You hop in, drive it about, and note that it only moves at the speed of 1 mile per hour.
Figure out a lower bound on the age of the golf cart.
If it was created at the factory on the island, it had to travel at least ten miles to have arrived at the edge of the island. Further, it made this trip going at most 1 mile per hour, so the cart in that case is at least ten hours old. This is nothing more than an algebraic manipulation of rate * time = distance, where rate and distance have been measured, and time is unknown.
Seeing the factory, you have evidence the cart was created there. Maybe it bears the same logo as the factory. Now, it's possible that an hour ago a boat from the ocean dropped it off, after creating it at its on-board factory two hours ago, but this would be pure fantasy as you see no evidence to suggest that explanation.
So, unless you're willing to entertain a skeptical explantion of a younger cart, you conclude based on the evidence that it is at least 10 hours old.
Light is completely analogous to the golf cart, having a constant speed.
A star is completely anaologous to the golf cart factory, as photons are emitted from the star, and the distance to stars can be measured via independment means, and sonhouse and twhitehead have described a few methods for doing this.
The observer at the edge of the island is analogous to observers of starlight on earth.
And the island is analogous to the universe.