02 May '12 15:18>
Originally posted by robbie carrobieNot even in self-defense?
no one has the right to deprive another of life, regardless of the circumstances. Life is
sacrosanct.
Originally posted by robbie carrobieSo, hypothetically speaking here, i'm walking home one night and am attacked by a couple of 'youths'. In the resulting melee i manage to get off one punch which connects firmly with one of my attackers jaw, as a result he is knocked unconcious and falls to the floor striking his head on the concrete pavement. He dies as a result of his injuries, where would that scenario put me in your view?
nope, not even in self defence, you can debilitate your assailant, but you cannot kill
them, otherwise its accidental manslaughter.
Originally posted by Proper Knobyou have committed involuntary manslaughter.
So, hypothetically speaking here, i'm walking home one night and am attacked by a couple of 'youths'. In the resulting melee i manage to get off one punch which connects firmly with one of my attackers jaw, as a result he is knocked unconcious and falls to the floor striking his head on the concrete pavement. He dies as a result of his injuries, where would that scenario put me in your view?
Originally posted by robbie carrobieNot in my country, it isn't.
nope, not even in self defence, you can debilitate your assailant, but you cannot kill
them, otherwise its accidental manslaughter.
Originally posted by SwissGambithmm, is there not a case recently and although i do not know the details, Zimmerman I
Not in my country, it isn't.
That's a bit too pacifist for me. It is the assailant who truly lacks respect for the lives of others; as the initiator of force, he is to blame for his own death.
Originally posted by robbie carrobieThe underlying issue here is the religious sanctity of life, we have sanctified human life to the tune of 7 billion plus, sanctified it so much we may starve to death, people are in fact starving to death right now. That's how sanctimonious religious people are. Sanctify us to death.
you have committed involuntary manslaughter.
Originally posted by Proper KnobI dont know what is prescribed in law, that's for the judiciary to decide. In ancient
What do you think should happen to me if the above occurred?
Originally posted by robbie carrobieWhat life?
no one has the right to deprive another of life, regardless of the circumstances. Life is
sacrosanct.
Originally posted by sonhouseif so say so it must be true. You sound like the RJH of materialists.
The underlying issue here is the religious sanctity of life, we have sanctified human life to the tune of 7 billion plus, sanctified it so much we may starve to death, people are in fact starving to death right now. That's how sanctimonious religious people are. Sanctify us to death.
Originally posted by robbie carrobieWhat would happen to me if i didn't run to another city?
I dont know what is prescribed in law, that's for the judiciary to decide. In ancient
times in Israel you could run to a city of refuge and state your case before the people
and who, satisfied that it was accidental and you had no ulterior motives, you could live
and work in that city unmolested.
Originally posted by robbie carrobieA person must have a reasonable fear of imminent bodily harm or death in order to have the right to use deadly force in self defense in most US states.
hmm, is there not a case recently and although i do not know the details, Zimmerman I
think it was, where a young man was killed by someone acting in apparent self
defence, when in fact, his alleged assailant was unarmed. Clearly such a stance is
open to abuse.
Originally posted by googlefudgeLife is life whether you seek to term it such or not is none of my concern. My stance is
What life?
An ant is more complex and capable of feeling than an embryo.
The pet hamster more capable of feeling or thought than a foetus.
Is it wrong to kill a plant, that's life.
How about microbes?
Are you guilty of the genocide of bacteria and viruses caused by your immune system?
No person has the right to commandeer another pe ...[text shortened]... them.
However it is not always possible to stop these people without using lethal force.
Originally posted by Proper KnobThat happens surprisingly often.
So, hypothetically speaking here, i'm walking home one night and am attacked by a couple of 'youths'. In the resulting melee i manage to get off one punch which connects firmly with one of my attackers jaw, as a result he is knocked unconcious and falls to the floor striking his head on the concrete pavement. He dies as a result of his injuries, where would that scenario put me in your view?