Go back
Well said, atheist...

Well said, atheist...

Spirituality

DC
Flamenco Sketches

Spain, in spirit

Joined
09 Sep 04
Moves
59422
Clock
25 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

I felt this is worthy of a post. He articulates a sentiment I've tried to express in this forum before.

Life is a gift to all of us. And yet, when one is an atheist, they are sometimes bothered by perhaps well meaning but nevertheless annoying theists, who accuse them of not caring about the life of anyone or anything. It's an odd reaction, because for the atheist, this life is it. In our view, we humans get a few decades on average, a tiny arc of consciousness across the infinite ocean of space-time, a blink of the cosmic eye, in which the universe can be uniquely aware of itself through each of us. And accepting that there is likely nothing afterward, nothing but the comforting non-existence that preceded conception, makes this time far more precious to the atheist, than many theists seem willing to contemplate.


http://www.dailykos.com/story/2005/11/15/23544/992

MM

Joined
28 Feb 06
Moves
10868
Clock
25 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by David C
I felt this is worthy of a post. He articulates a sentiment I've tried to express in this forum before.

Life is a gift to all of us. And yet, when one is an atheist, they are sometimes bothered by perhaps well meaning but nevertheless annoying theists, who accuse them of not caring about the life of anyone or anything. It's an odd reaction, beca ...[text shortened]... lling to contemplate.


[b]http://www.dailykos.com/story/2005/11/15/23544/992
[/b]
Worth a rec!
I wonder if life after death scenarios as in theism and reincarnation are really a lack of humilty, believing oneself too important to die....

a
Andrew Mannion

Melbourne, Australia

Joined
17 Feb 04
Moves
54000
Clock
25 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mister Meaner
Worth a rec!
I wonder if life after death scenarios as in theism and reincarnation are really a lack of humilty, believing oneself too important to die....
I think it's more a sense of fear, and of 'this can't be all' pleading ...

t
True X X Xian

The Lord's Army

Joined
18 Jul 04
Moves
8353
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by amannion
I think it's more a sense of fear, and of 'this can't be all' pleading ...
I'm not sure which fate I find more(or less) comforting:

1) Vanishing from existence and memory

or

2) Living eternally

R

Joined
17 May 05
Moves
6676
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

It's not just the desire for existence. The desire for some eternal justice factors into it since life is unfair.

R

Joined
17 May 05
Moves
6676
Clock
26 Apr 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by David C
I felt this is worthy of a post. He articulates a sentiment I've tried to express in this forum before.

Life is a gift to all of us. And yet, when one is an atheist, they are sometimes bothered by perhaps well meaning but nevertheless annoying theists, who accuse them of not caring about the life of anyone or anything. It's an odd reaction, beca ...[text shortened]... lling to contemplate.


[b]http://www.dailykos.com/story/2005/11/15/23544/992
[/b]
Well, that's fine and dandy if everyone thought altruistically. Take a look around pal. Nature has programmed us with lots of evil "ME" genes geared for survival. Even the founders of america, atheists at heart, had to declare that men were created equal with inalienable rights to justify their rebellion.

a
Andrew Mannion

Melbourne, Australia

Joined
17 Feb 04
Moves
54000
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Regicidal
It's not just the desire for existence. The desire for some eternal justice factors into it since life is unfair.
Why is life unfair?
It just is. Life is life. Any notion of fairness or otherwise must surely be a anthropomorphic filter that we impose on it.

a
Andrew Mannion

Melbourne, Australia

Joined
17 Feb 04
Moves
54000
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Regicidal
Well, that's fine and dandy if everyone thought altruistically. Take a look around pal. Nature has programmed us with lots of evil "ME" genes geared for survival. Even the founders of america, atheists at heart, had to declare that men were created equal with inalienable rights to justify their rebellion.
Just the other day I listened to a speech given by Richard Dawkins commemorating 30 years since the release of 'The Selfish Gene'. He suggested that the title was probably a mistake and had created much controversy where none was needed. He suggested an alternative title - 'The Altruistic Gene' might've been better.

R

Joined
17 May 05
Moves
6676
Clock
26 Apr 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by amannion
Why is life unfair?
It just is. Life is life. Any notion of fairness or otherwise must surely be a anthropomorphic filter that we impose on it.
alright
The desire for some eternal justice factors into it since life is perceived unfair.
happy?

a
Andrew Mannion

Melbourne, Australia

Joined
17 Feb 04
Moves
54000
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Regicidal
alright
The desire for some eternal justice factors into it since life is perceived unfair.
happy?
Very.

KellyJay
Walk your Faith

USA

Joined
24 May 04
Moves
160034
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Regicidal
It's not just the desire for existence. The desire for some eternal justice factors into it since life is unfair.
Why do you think life is unfair?
Kelly

rwingett
Ming the Merciless

Royal Oak, MI

Joined
09 Sep 01
Moves
27626
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Regicidal
Well, that's fine and dandy if everyone thought altruistically. Take a look around pal. Nature has programmed us with lots of evil "ME" genes geared for survival. Even the founders of america, atheists at heart, had to declare that men were created equal with inalienable rights to justify their rebellion.
What has accepting the finitude of one's life got to do with altruism? Atheists would want to prolong their lives as long as possible since they accept that they only have one life to live.

The founding fathers were not atheists. They were largely deists. And although deists at that time were "slandered" as being atheists, the charge was not true.

r
petting the cat

On Clique Beach

Joined
23 Dec 05
Moves
28199
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by David C
I felt this is worthy of a post. He articulates a sentiment I've tried to express in this forum before.

Life is a gift to all of us. And yet, when one is an atheist, they are sometimes bothered by perhaps well meaning but nevertheless annoying theists, who accuse them of not caring about the life of anyone or anything. It's an odd reaction, beca ...[text shortened]... lling to contemplate.


[b]http://www.dailykos.com/story/2005/11/15/23544/992
[/b]
Really? To the atheists I know personally, disbelief in a higher power or any sort of existence after death means that they can do whatever they please in this life and treat people consistantly badly. They can enjoy causing others pain and fear because there is no reason not to. They lie and steal as part of their firm belief in survival of the fittest, interpreting *fittest* to mean whoever can hurt the most people and benefit from it. Since they believe there is no one to answer to, then there is no morality, only laws that are sometimes enforced but often not. Perhaps life is precious to SOME atheists, just as SOME people with religions are nasty to people of other religions or atheists.

a
Andrew Mannion

Melbourne, Australia

Joined
17 Feb 04
Moves
54000
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by reader1107
Really? To the atheists I know personally, disbelief in a higher power or any sort of existence after death means that they can do whatever they please in this life and treat people consistantly badly. They can enjoy causing others pain and fear because there is no reason not to. They lie and steal as part of their firm belief in survival of the fittes ...[text shortened]... atheists, just as SOME people with religions are nasty to people of other religions or atheists.
Wow, the atheists you know sound like bastards. And you sound like you've had enough. Why do you have anything to do with them?
(Do you REALLY know people like that? C'mon you can be straight with us.)

t
True X X Xian

The Lord's Army

Joined
18 Jul 04
Moves
8353
Clock
26 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by reader1107
Really? To the atheists I know personally, disbelief in a higher power or any sort of existence after death means that they can do whatever they please in this life and treat people consistantly badly. They can enjoy causing others pain and fear because there is no reason not to. They lie and steal as part of their firm belief in survival of the fittes ...[text shortened]... atheists, just as SOME people with religions are nasty to people of other religions or atheists.
You sound like you don't know any actual atheists, but rather you know a bunch of sadistic jerks that you mistakenly call atheists.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.