Go back
what if we're all wrong?

what if we're all wrong?

Spirituality

g

Pepperland

Joined
30 May 07
Moves
12892
Clock
04 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

What if all religions were wrong, and failed to understand what God is really about?

Maybe we didn't get what Jesus' message was all about.

If we had, our world would have been much better.

Of course, this is just a question, it may not be true, but anyway let's think out of the box just this time.

divegeester
watching in dismay

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120597
Clock
04 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by generalissimo
What if all religions were wrong, and failed to understand what God is really about?

Maybe we didn't get what Jesus' message was all about.

If we had, our world would have been much better.

Of course, this is just a question, it may not be true, but anyway let's think out of the box just this time.
Good point and probably they way it actually is.

A
The 'edit'or

converging to it

Joined
21 Aug 06
Moves
11479
Clock
04 Apr 09
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

I haven't had enough conversations with you to decide whether or whether not you are a theist and lack the inclnation to do any research on the matter 🙂 but I can agree to an extent with your OP. (I don't yet know if there is a god at all however, and have little reason to invoke one!)

From my perspective, I see no reason to compare any two religions and find that one is more plausible than the other. However, I'm quite sure that if there is a god (big *if* btw), and Jesus existed then despite the suggestion that he may have been wise and better informed than his peers he has been venerated to a status he neither deserves nor would have wanted by primitive folk enthralled by his charisma.

I find any human (or creature) pretentious to define an entity which by definition lies outside its ability to perceive in any way other than its supposed manifestation in our dimensions; hence I am quite sure that all religions are indeed wrong.

d

Break-twitching

Joined
30 Nov 08
Moves
1228
Clock
05 Apr 09
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by generalissimo
What if all religions were wrong, and failed to understand what God is really about?

Maybe we didn't get what Jesus' message was all about.

If we had, our world would have been much better.

Of course, this is just a question, it may not be true, but anyway let's think out of the box just this time.
It's not that man didn't get the messages and instructions from Jesus, it's that man refuses to live by them.

i

Felicific Forest

Joined
15 Dec 02
Moves
49429
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by generalissimo
What if all religions were wrong, and failed to understand what God is really about?

Maybe we didn't get what Jesus' message was all about.

If we had, our world would have been much better.

Of course, this is just a question, it may not be true, but anyway let's think out of the box just this time.
What if Jesus's teachings, as taught to us by the RC Church, are right ?

P

Joined
06 May 05
Moves
9174
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by generalissimo
What if all religions were wrong, and failed to understand what God is really about?

Maybe we didn't get what Jesus' message was all about.

If we had, our world would have been much better.

Of course, this is just a question, it may not be true, but anyway let's think out of the box just this time.
If all religions were wrong then Jesus wasn't divine at all.

S
Done Asking

Washington, D.C.

Joined
11 Oct 06
Moves
3464
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Agerg
I haven't had enough conversations with you to decide whether or whether not you are a theist and lack the inclnation to do any research on the matter 🙂 but I can agree to an extent with your OP. (I don't yet know if there is a god at all however, and have little reason to invoke one!)

From my perspective, I see no reason to compare any two religions and f ...[text shortened]... d manifestation in our dimensions; hence I am quite sure that all religions are indeed wrong.
Although Buddhism is classified as a religion, I am not at all convinced it is wrong; at least it isn't wrong in the same way theistic religions are wrong.

I think Buddhist philosophy makes a lot of valid points; the truth of its message as a religion I leave to others.

I know I have benefited greatly from insight meditation and the Buddhist perspective on many of life's greatest challenges, such as coping with the death of one's child.

You don't have to join up, be a card carrying Buddhist, etc. But you can take advantage of what this ancient discipline has to offer. I especially like the fact that nothing I have learned or heard in Buddhism conflicts in the least with the scientific rationalism I learned from my father.

S
Done Asking

Washington, D.C.

Joined
11 Oct 06
Moves
3464
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ivanhoe
What if Jesus's teachings, as taught to us by the RC Church, are right ?
How on Earth could they be? The very idea makes me want to quote Ricky Gervais' catchphrase from the Extras: Is he having a laugh?

S
Done Asking

Washington, D.C.

Joined
11 Oct 06
Moves
3464
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by PsychoPawn
If all religions were wrong then Jesus wasn't divine at all.
but he was a wonderful guy -- and think of all the people who would lose their authority if we accepted the idea that Jesus was just a man, like the Buddha, with some interesting ideas.

divegeester
watching in dismay

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120597
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by PsychoPawn
If all religions were wrong then Jesus wasn't divine at all.
Depends which bits are wrong of course

b

Joined
15 Oct 07
Moves
4056
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

I don't believe that the question of if we are wrong is the right one to be asking.

What matter does it make if the existence of religion is false? The key factor to any religion is the way of life. If we put aside the fact that there is a God, and that Jesus is the Saviour of man, the ideas and thoughts that he puts forward are nonetheless still valid.

I don't think we should be worrying about if we got the message from God wrong, as much as simply living our life in a proper way. Even if Jesus wasn't the saviour, the ideaology that he put forward would, if everyone abided by it, create a much better society. If we look at it this way, then religion isn't the crucial factor, so much as living our life according to the morals that are placed forward.

d

Break-twitching

Joined
30 Nov 08
Moves
1228
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by banx99
I don't believe that the question of if we are wrong is the right one to be asking.

What matter does it make if the existence of religion is false? The key factor to any religion is the way of life. If we put aside the fact that there is a God, and that Jesus is the Saviour of man, the ideas and thoughts that he puts forward are nonetheless still valid.
...[text shortened]... crucial factor, so much as living our life according to the morals that are placed forward.
Good statement.....I like it.

b

Joined
15 Oct 07
Moves
4056
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Yay! Someone agrees with me

divegeester
watching in dismay

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120597
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by banx99
Yay! Someone agrees with me
Yes, I agree also, up to a point. However although what you are saying is theoretically appealing, it is basically a form of humanism I think; I.E. the concept of godly virtues without God.

Christianity, (Jesus) teaches that “without me you can do nothing”, and that the purpose of spiritual regeneration is to enable the believer to experience a new spirit enabled life through the power of the spirit of god.

Currently on a macro level, there is precious little evidence of people leading this type of life and what organised churches there are, are often run by charlatans who bring the name of our God into disrepute.

g

Pepperland

Joined
30 May 07
Moves
12892
Clock
05 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ivanhoe
What if Jesus's teachings, as taught to us by the RC Church, are right ?
I think some of it is, but some of it is just bulls**t.

Most religions have some good points, but I don't think there is one religion that got it all right.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.