Originally posted by Joe Fist
[b]That sounds a bit like the Calvinist view, which I'm not too sure I entirely agree with. Maybe God installed the initial perfect parameters, knowing full well that with free will, man will wreck it. However there will also be millions throughout history who will choose to serve Him. God did not however abandon His creation, intervening most notably with ...[text shortened]...
Really? I would think you would be more from the point of view to “turn the other cheek”, no?
I’m not really familiar with Calvin but if God did create us knowing that many would take advantage of all the aspects of free will isn’t that, if anything, somewhat bizarre?
[/b]
True. I can't really say for sure, I hope I'm not being redundant, and as I said before theology is not my forte, but here's a few pointers.
1. Compared to God, man is very insignificant.
2. God created man so that man can worship God of his own free will.
3. This very creative act allows the opposite, that man can worship himselft or anything else he pleases.
4. I believe man has an emptiness that can only be filled by God, and therefore he is always driven towards God. As proof I cite the history of mankind and how the worship of a deity has always existed. (There are exceptions to this generalisation)
5. I believe man has a conscience (alluded to earlier) which as you said can be influenced by society, but generally holds things such as killing, stealing etc, to be morally wrong. It is a component of Natural Law and could be defined as The Knowledge of Good and Evil, which Adam partook of before the right time.
6. Therefore I believe each individual has enough in their soul, to point him/her towards God.
7. God is holy and cannot tolerate sin ie. evil. Therefore if mankind chooses evil and disregards Gods moral law and the perfect atonement of Christ, he is deserving of eternal punishment.
I hope I'm not muddying the water.
I guess this is another point where you and I differ because I honestly cannot see where any group (Christian or any sect) where the God they believe in would punish a race or a group of people for having different beliefs? If God created all people then didn’t He create races such as the ones of Asian heritage that basically had no concept or contact with Christ or the Bible and founded their own beliefs?
I believe God will judge us according to the light we have recieved. If somebody has never heard of Jesus Christ, I can't believe God will punish them for their ignorance. That is where my concepts of "emptyness" and "conscience" come in. Through these two, God has actually revealed Himself to everybody. If man still choses to disregard them, well then they are judged by their own deeds.
Through the Bible though, God has revealed an even higher standard of moral living.
Aside: There are however huge incompatibilities with eastern religions which cannot be reconciled to Christianity.
But let’s take the two most current tragedies that have occurred: Hurricane Katrina destruction of the Gulf Coast and the deaths resulting in the stampede in Iraq. As far as Katrina goes, I would guess many of these victims were most likely Christian and, according to news reports, many of them were somewhat poverty stricken to begin with. Reports believe that many of the undiscovered bodies are that of children but my point is why would God wreak such havoc?
Here's some options:
1. Katrina was caused by God.
2. Katrina was caused by the forces of nature and can be clearly explained scientifically, but God allowed it to happen.
My option would be 2. Now why did God allow it? That is where I think the concept of original sin and the curse come in. I'm quite self loathing at the moment, because pontification is also not my forte, but here goes...
1. God created man and placed him in paradise.
2. Adam was given dominion over the whole earth.
2. Mankind rebelled against God.
3. God cursed man and the earth.
4. Because of the curse, God chooses not to intervene when the forces of nature wreak havoc on earth.
In the case of the stampede it could be effectively argued that God was not in any way responsible for this. The Iraq government supposedly issued some false reports of a suicide bomber in the crowd which caused widespread panic.
Agree with you here.
Sure Like Katrina, many children were killed either by suffocation through the crowd or being shoved into the Tigris River. I imagine the majority of these people, if not all, were not Christian so I ask a variation of the same question above: Do you really believe a horrific tragedy such as this is due to the fact that these people are not Christian and that God intervened to wipe them out?
I believe that until children are old enough to be able to consciously decide, they don't fall under Gods judgement. As I explained above, I don't believe that God judges you according to whether one calls oneself a Christian, but rather according to the individual choices we make in life and the essence of our soul.
I think you make an excellent point here. Once we expose ourselves enough times to what we know or what we have been told is “inappropriate”, we tend to deaden our sense of what we should do and our morality becomes more “flexible”, per se. I am not even saying porn in inappropriate (well it is for minors sure).
Maybe porn was a bit of a controversial one, it was just the first one that came to mind. But the concept remains the same.
Really? I would think you would be more from the point of view to “turn the other cheek”, no?
On a personal level, yes. I believe one should turn the other cheek, love the person who has wronged us, and pray for their salvation.
This however doesn't mean that somebody shouldn't be held accountable for their actions.
On a governmental level, which as I said is more on a political level, I believe that the government has a mandate to serve the justice of God. After the due process of law and a fair trial where somebody is found guilty beyond reasonable doubt, they should get their due punishment... Which in a Biblical sense, for petty crimes is not a prison sentence, but restoration.