Originally posted by KazetNagorra
So the people who want the Philly Orchestra to continue should donate money to them, and perhaps they should charge more for their concerts or pay their musicians less. I don't see why someone who doesn't care about orchestral music should be forced to contribute towards it.
Charge more for their concerts -> no one will be able to afford to go
Pay their musicians less -> not possible (musicians are hardly seriously paid, compared to let's say a plumber or so, and compare the amount of study and hard work needed for those two)
Someone who doesn't necessarily care about orchestral music should be forced to contribute towards it, because that's how a society works. You pay taxes and some people in charge decide what's best for the country.
Having institutions like symphony orchestras (or schools, or hospitals, or music schools, etc. etc.) is almost always in a country's best interest.
Besides, research has shown (at least in The Netherlands, where they've
very recently decided to cut major art (and mainly music) funding) that for each dollar/euro that goes to arts you get multiple dollars/euros back.
So a society actually only gets things back from 'being forced to contribute towards it'. Funding the arts (and music in particular since I know most about it) is, has always been or, if not, should be a major governmental issue.
Imagine having a talented child and not being able to show it Van Gogh, Monet, Rembrandt, Chagall, or let it listen to Bach, Beethoven, Chopin, Mozart (to name 'just' a few). And I don't mean CD's (made by artists who were most of the time able to get where they are because at some point they were helped by governmental funding, aside from having worked their asses off for their entire lives) but the real thing.
Music is one of those things that evolved as mankind evolved.
Things like making money and other (extremely boring) stuff existed since man existed, in one way or another.
Focusing only on this while wiping out that which makes us the intelligent and evolved beings we are today will only put us back. It might sound dramatic and the results will not be immediate, but eventually it will be this way.
Maybe you care about special things that make us humans with emotions and feeling for things we can't quite understand (like really good beautiful music or beautiful paintings).
Maybe you don't. In that case, welcome back to the stone age.