07 Mar 06
Originally posted by DoctorScribblesYou and Rwingnutt should organise a debate to be judged by your peers.
Well, we'll just see who wins. I wasn't really impressed by the other singer/songwriter or cover entries, and none of the other lyrics struck me as memorable.
The ethics of taking part in light hearted competition...
You could take the "I vote for my own stuff to try to ensure I win" side of the debate, and the wingnutt could take the "I abstain from voting when the rules state that I can't vote for myself, to try to ensure I win" side.
It'd be great.
D
07 Mar 06
Best Band: sonhouse
Best Singer/Songwriter: Cribs
Best Vocal/Instrumental: Nordlys
Best Cover: shavixmir
Best Computer track: Gatecrasher
Best Composer: Nordlys
Best Musician(s) (technique/ability): Nordlys
Best Lyrics: Cribs
Best Overall Submission: Aurora Borealis - Nordlys
07 Mar 06
Originally posted by RagnorakWere there rules against voting for one's own submissions? If so, I'll withdraw my votes for myself.
You and Rwingnutt should organise a debate to be judged by your peers.
The ethics of taking part in light hearted competition...
You could take the "I vote for my own stuff to try to ensure I win" side of the debate, and the wingnutt could take the "I abstain from voting when the rules state that I can't vote for myself, to try to ensure I win" side.
It'd be great.
D
07 Mar 06
Originally posted by DoctorScribblesI don't think I ever said so, but I had envisaged (due to previous competition voting practices) that people would refrain from doing so. But if you really think your music is better than the others in that category and you are being impartial, then the vote may stand I guess.
Were there rules against voting for one's own submissions? If so, I'll withdraw my votes for myself.
07 Mar 06
Ok, after a careful and impartial reconsideration, I have decided to recast my vote...
Best Computer track: Starrman2
Cover: Shavixmir1
Instrumental/Vocalist: sonhouse
Band: darvlay
Singer/Songwriter: snoop cribsy cribs
Best Musician(s): sonhouse
Best Overall Submission: Phlab
Best Composer: dk3nny
Best Lyrics: Phlab
Best Humourous song: Phlab
D
07 Mar 06
Originally posted by StarrmanThat I think should be called Jazzy riff. I remember that name
Lol, no, what I mean is, the track which really is 'the river' was previously called 'another ragged phoenix' on the site. What should I now call the track which was previously called 'the river'? is it 'another ragged phoenix'?
or something like it sticking in my memory, composed by Kevin.
I am waiting for some stuff from my daughter Heather, she has
an MA in music from Wesleyan, she teaches on university level
in Brazil.