Clan System Request for Proposals

Russ

RHP Code Monkey

Site Ideas

29 Dec 16 11:53

moonbus

Über-Nerd (emeritus)

Joined: 31 May 12
Moves: 9614

13 Jan 17 22:10

Individuals' clan ratings to be based only on clan games, decoupled from all non-clan ratings.

~~robbie carrobie~~

Joined: 26 Aug 07
Moves: 38239

13 Jan 17 22:15

-2

Originally posted by moonbus
Individuals' clan ratings to be based only on clan games, decoupled from all non-clan ratings.

yes, this would be an excellent idea.

Giannotti

Joined: 17 Jun 08
Moves: 179883

13 Jan 17 22:57

Originally posted by my2sons
Finally, some good suggestions. I like everything you have proposed plus having a clan only rating.🙂

i'm in favor of a 'clan rating' as well, i think we need to add it to the list

mghrn55

Joined: 07 Feb 09
Moves: 151917

13 Jan 17 23:17

-1

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
yes I am all for it. I expect your rating to rise from 1700 to 1900

Nice to see we are on the same page.
Except for the cheap shot. 😀

lstcyr

Victor, New York

Joined: 08 May 09
Moves: 2184462

13 Jan 17 23:40

-1

Originally posted by mghrn55
You missed my point.
My question was ....
Why switch to ELO rating system when we already have a formula ?

I fully support decouple of clan rating from tournament rating.

I think we're saying the same thing. I don't like ELO and agree that the existing formula for just clan games solves the problem.

padger

Here

Joined: 31 May 06
Moves: 416756

14 Jan 17 06:04

-2

Originally posted by moonbus
Individuals' clan ratings to be based only on clan games, decoupled from all non-clan ratings.

Sandbaggers use multiple games to resign on to lower their rating
If my proposal was taken up they could no longer do this to reduce their rating
Doing away with the need for different ratings
If it keeps ratings a little higher so what
I am sure most people would like to keep a respectable rating

Mctayto

Highlander

Planet Earth

Joined: 10 Dec 04
Moves: 1047875

14 Jan 17 09:25

-4

Originally posted by padger
Sandbaggers use multiple games to resign on to lower their rating
If my proposal was taken up they could no longer do this to reduce their rating
Doing away with the need for different ratings
If it keeps ratings a little higher so what
I am sure most people would like to keep a respectable rating

You have been 1500 rating and currently under 1200 rating.
Is this what you mean by sandbagging 😉

padger

Here

Joined: 31 May 06
Moves: 416756

14 Jan 17 09:29

-2

Originally posted by Mctayto
You have been 1500 rating and currently under 1200 rating.
Is this what you mean by sandbagging 😉

Starting to sweat are we ?
You had better get rid of all those games that you have got running

Mctayto

Highlander

Planet Earth

Joined: 10 Dec 04
Moves: 1047875

14 Jan 17 10:17

-5

Originally posted by padger
Starting to sweat are we ?
You had better get rid of all those games that you have got running

Not at all, simply showing that there are many wolves in sheep clothing 😉

roma45

st johnstone

Joined: 14 Nov 09
Moves: 439388

14 Jan 17 11:46

-2

Originally posted by Mctayto
Not at all, simply showing that there are many wolves in sheep clothing 😉

I am tempted to make a sheep joke but that will be off topic
Still have to close the collusion loophole no system will do that only points removal and clan suspensions will cure the site cancer

padger

Here

Joined: 31 May 06
Moves: 416756

14 Jan 17 12:07

-2

Originally posted by roma45
I am tempted to make a sheep joke but that will be off topic
Still have to close the collusion loophole no system will do that only points removal and clan suspensions will cure the site cancer

Again in my proposal you cannot play the same clan for 90 days this would have cut Robbies points total by almost 450
But I agree there should be some sort of redress for what went on last year

mghrn55