06 Mar '08 00:54>
Will there be a 20-game provisional period for each club?
It seems that if engines are still banned site-wide, you're not really removing any of the burden from the site-wide admins (game moderation team or what have you), because you still have to police cheating everywhere. Maybe some of the more "reputable" clubs could kick out cheaters faster based on their own policies, or something. But this in itself could lead to a lot of in-fighting and arguments.
I'm not sure I'm getting why being in a club would be a compelling experience. If I'm more interested in a club rating than the site rating, that seems like kind of an admission that the site rating is not trustworthy. I'm not sure if you're allowed to join multiple clubs, but if everyone is in 3 or 4 clubs, I think everyone will just look at whichever rating is displayed most prominently in the profile anyway.
I wonder what percentage of your opponents you would generally expect to come from one of your own clubs. If it's fairly small, then it will take quite a long time for your club ratings to become reliable.
It seems that if engines are still banned site-wide, you're not really removing any of the burden from the site-wide admins (game moderation team or what have you), because you still have to police cheating everywhere. Maybe some of the more "reputable" clubs could kick out cheaters faster based on their own policies, or something. But this in itself could lead to a lot of in-fighting and arguments.
I'm not sure I'm getting why being in a club would be a compelling experience. If I'm more interested in a club rating than the site rating, that seems like kind of an admission that the site rating is not trustworthy. I'm not sure if you're allowed to join multiple clubs, but if everyone is in 3 or 4 clubs, I think everyone will just look at whichever rating is displayed most prominently in the profile anyway.
I wonder what percentage of your opponents you would generally expect to come from one of your own clubs. If it's fairly small, then it will take quite a long time for your club ratings to become reliable.