Originally posted by Suzianne
Hebrews 11:4 says that "By faith Abel offered up a more excellent sacrifice than Cain". So presumably, Cain's offering was not made "by faith". Some Bible commentary says that Cain's offering was the effort of "dead religion", but I'm not sure what this means.
I think I meant "religion" in a negative sense, an attempt to reach unto God not according to revelation. Cain initiated that matter.
God had revealed to Adam and Eve a way that He could be approached, I believe. It is not explicitly told us in the Bible. I think Adam and Eve approached God through the sacrifice of an animal with blood.
Abel received this instruction and understood it. Cain initiated something of his own concept. That was to approach God through the works of his own labor on the crops that he grew. His offering was rejected.
I am saying Cain invented religion. Some people would have a point in saying it was religion in a dead and negative sense. I'd be reasonably satisfied with either understanding.
1.) Cain invented the first religion of man.
2.) Cain invented the first "dead" religion.