Originally posted by whodey
Why do we then have children if the world is such a terrible place? Are we then just as culpable, if not more so, as God is, seeing as how we see things better than he?
First, it is trivially obvious that if God is as amazing as his admirers claim, then no one can be more culpable for the state of the world than he. The buck stops with him.
To answer your quesiton. One reason why humans still have children is that nearly all of them possess an instinctive drive to reproduce. The god we are discussing though is free of such impulses. He made his decision without the distraction of any hormones.
Another reason is that, as Satan observed earlier in this thread, humans generally take very good care of their offspring. They go to great lengths to protect their offspring from the perils of nature. Of course, nature is not in the parents power to control and so some will suffer despite the parents best attempts. The xian god on the otherhand watches on as millions of his "children" die horrific and agonizing deaths. Unlike humans, he
can control nature. At the very least the xian god should allow everyone to die painlessly. Certianly a real parent would do this for their child if they could.
Finally, humans, unlike the xian god, do not know their child's future with certainty. From the last point it is clear that they have some reason to believe that they can make their child's life generally enjoyable. If they did have perfect foresight though, then we would certainly observe parents being prudent about which offspring they brought into the world. If I knew with certainty that the child I was about to sire would live a life of tremendous pain and misery, more pain and misery than laughter and love, then I would not participate in conceiving it. But then how culpable this god must be! He knows with certainty which people will live eternally in Hell. Only a monstrous and selfish parent would bring such a person into existence!