Originally posted by Zahlanzi
he is certainly not omnipotent.
if god would stop all evil would that make him benevolent? how benevolent would he be towards evil?
how benevolent is a person that holds you by the hand and solves all your problems?(eg evil's influence in your life)
how benevolent is a person that holds you by the hand and solves all your problems?(eg evil's influence in your life)
In its strongest form, the argument from evil doesn't claim that God's existence is incompatible with all conceivable "evil". For example, if one could show that certain instances of what we might otherwise call "evil" are actually logically necessary for some greater good, then they should pose no problem for the theist.
So I will provide an example of unnecessary suffering, one that I think displays the problem of evil in more or less its full strength. It's an example I have already raised before in this forum, and no theist has come with any reasonable response to it. It is something that occurred relatively frequently in the past before advances in medical science allowed us to deal reliably with the problem:
A baby is born with an intestinal obstruction, and there is no known procedure yet available to save her. Over the course of several extremely painful days (including severe dehydration), she suffers, withers, and dies. Such an instance of suffering seems unnecessary for any greater good or for any project ends that an all-powerful, all-knowing, and all-loving god could have for his subjects. So if God exists, then why did this fate, in fact, befall many neonates (duodenal atresia, often with a link to Down's syndrome -- it was deadly before we could treat it)?