Originally posted by jaywill
"God always was?" "God existed before time ??"
Sentences like this only show the limitation of human language.
And though it may break our hearts to have to admit it, they also show the limitation of the human mind.
(Perish the thought, that our minds be limited!)
…"God always was?"…
That isn’t one of the phrases that I see as a self-contradiction:
As I had just said in my previous post, you can have, without logical self-contradiction:
1, “God HAS ALWAYS existed "INSIDE" the realms of TIME”
-which I presume is what is generally meant by the words: “God always was” ?
…"God existed before time ??"
only show the limitation of human LANGUAGE.
..…(my emphasis)
No, sentences like this that are asserting a logical contradiction and which people accept as valid despite this show the limitation of human RATIONALITY. This isn’t therefore just about mere syntax.
If “God existed BEFORE TIME” then there was a “BEFORE TIME” 😛 (which is a self contradiction if you haven’t noticed)
Can you simultaneously have both “P” and “not P” being true in reality?
(where “P” is any valid proposition that can therefore only be either true or false)