Go back
greater isreal

greater isreal

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Rajk999 said
Ok. You say they will be stopped, but history is not on your side unless you have something that has changed over the last 75 years. If anything the balance of power betweenn 1948, when both sides were pretty equal, and today shows the Jews have grown exponentially while the opposing Arabs have basically nothing worthwile with which to fight the Jews.
History has not been on the jewish side either for 2000 years!
A spike in influence in the last 75 years is not guaranteeing any sort of continued supremacy for even the near future. The moment US pulls the plug, Israel will choke.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@sameeh said
It is hypocritical though, to end a discussion without acknowledging that your side has done far more atrocities than the other side even after being presented with ample evidence, and then continuing to claim only the other side is evil.

If you do acknowledge that Israel has overstepped the moral line multiple times in the past, then yes, I will agree to end that discussion. If not, then you haven't ended a discussion - rather you only ran away from it.
I am hypocritical because I dont share your opinion?
Thats typical of Islam.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@sameeh said
History has not been on the jewish side either for 2000 years!
A spike in influence in the last 75 years is not guaranteeing any sort of continued supremacy for even the near future. The moment US pulls the plug, Israel will choke.
We will have to wait and see. Nothing to discuss here.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Rajk999 said
I am hypocritical because I dont share your opinion?
Thats typical of Islam.
No. I clearly said why you are hypocritical, and you seem to ignore/obscure that.
You are hypocritical because you ignore/avoid responding to evidence/instances when Israel has clearly violated morality and human rights norms, but accuse Palestinians of the same cruelty.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Rajk999 said
We will have to wait and see. Nothing to discuss here.
Well, you are the one who wanted to discuss the future, not me 🙂

Vote Up
Vote Down

@sameeh said
No. I clearly said why you are hypocritical, and you seem to ignore/obscure that.
You are hypocritical because you ignore/avoid responding to evidence/instances when Israel has clearly violated morality and human rights norms, but accuse Palestinians of the same cruelty.
There were violations of human rights on both sides. I have no time to waste analysing which side had more or less. You knock yourself out and do it.

The fact is that Palestine became a British territory in 1915, and therefore OWNED BY THE QUEEN, who under colonial rule can do whatever she pleased with it. This was normal life in 1915. It was the very same way the Ottoman Empire took Palestine from the Mamluk Sultanate some 500 years before ... by war, and they owned Palestine and did whatever they wanted with it.

It is only because the Jews got a portion of Palestine in 1948, that this matter became an issue. Its all about Jew hatred.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@sameeh said
Well, you are the one who wanted to discuss the future, not me 🙂
The future is Palestine is owned by the Jews. Get used to it. Arabs living in Palestine will be naturalised and become Arab Israelis and will be part of Israel. This 75 year old war is about to end. Those who resist are going to die.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Rajk999 said
There were violations of human rights on both sides. I have no time to waste analysing which side had more or less. You knock yourself out and do it.

The fact is that Palestine became a British territory in 1915, and therefore OWNED BY THE QUEEN, who under colonial rule can do whatever she pleased with it. This was normal life in 1915. It was the very same way the Otto ...[text shortened]... ews got a portion of Palestine in 1948, that this matter became an issue. Its all about Jew hatred.
I have explained the inherent hypocrisy in this already, but let me repeat that, since you seem to have selective amnesia once again.

When the Queen decided to give it to Jews "as she pleased", this wasn;t a unilateral decision by a reigning monarch, but in reality the decision of a democratic goveernment in Britain after much debate in public. The ranking argument in favour of israel, during this "democratic" public discourse, was that Jewish nationalism was something to be respected.
What the same "democratic" discourse conveniently ignored, is the nationalistic rights of the Palestinians who already lived there.
(When I asked you what would you have done if you lived in those times, you categorically said your hatred of muslims would have made you side with the Jews. Pretty much the same thing happened in reality)

So, polishing this off as an accident from colonial times is the lamest argument you can come up with. Please stop spewing this kind of nonsense. It was a racist decision, reeking of hatred for the Palestinians. Opposition to this is not hatred for Jews, its just a desire for decent civilized behaviour amongst peoples.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Rajk999 said
The future is Palestine is owned by the Jews. Get used to it. Arabs living in Palestine will be naturalised and become Arab Israelis and will be part of Israel. This 75 year old war is about to end. Those who resist are going to die.
Thus spoke the Nazis in 1939 ;-)


@sameeh said
I have explained the inherent hypocrisy in this already, but let me repeat that, since you seem to have selective amnesia once again.

When the Queen decided to give it to Jews "as she pleased", this wasn;t a unilateral decision by a reigning monarch, but in reality the decision of a democratic goveernment in Britain after much debate in public. The ranking argument in favou ...[text shortened]... on to this is not hatred for Jews, its just a desire for decent civilized behaviour amongst peoples.
I explained my position regarding how the Jews got Palestine and Im not doing it again. You dwell on the past .. good for you

Islam is a dangerous religion. I gave umpteen reasons why. They kill people who do not adhere to their stupid religion. So yes I hate that religion and all who follow it. So Im glad they did not and can never get a foothold on Palestine. Thank God.

Thank God for the British, and America, and all who support the Jews.

A great new day is coming in Palestine.


@Rajk999 said
I explained my position regarding how the Jews got Palestine and Im not doing it again. You dwell on the past .. good for you

Islam is a dangerous religion. I gave umpteen reasons why. They kill people who do not adhere to their stupid religion. So yes I hate that religion and all who follow it. So Im glad they did not and can never get a foothold on Palestine. Thank ...[text shortened]... the British, and America, and all who support the Jews.

A great new day is coming in Palestine.
Just responding in kind..

Israel is a dangerous country. I gave umpteen reasons why. They kill people who stand in the way of their colonial land grabbing. So yes, I hate that country and all who support it. So I will be glad when their imperialist project falls apart one day, and justice will be done.
Thank God for all the millions of free and just people (even Jews in Israel!!) who protest against atrocities of the Israeli government!

And i hope you have a great day 🙂