@moonbus saidAre you suggesting that if a machine could do that it would prove it was conscious?
Ask a machine to tell you a joke. An original one, not one it found on the Internet.
I don’t think I could come up with an original joke on command. Does that prove something about me?
@AThousandYoung saidPhilosophically, you can only be confident about the existence of your own consciousness. That's because human brains give rise to the experience of consciousness. "Je pense donc je suis." And yet, practically, obviously, there are tools to measure consciousness. You mention EEG.
You think we have a method to measure consciousness?
Neuroscientists study consciousness by studying patterns of electric discharges with an EEG.
What in your extensive education gave you the idea that we had a consciousness measuring device that only works on biological systems?
Because you could easily study electric discharges in a metal device like a nonbi ...[text shortened]... why such well educated scientist is so vague about scientific topics.
“You just measure it” smh
It appears to be measurable. Science measures it most reliably when it goes away, rather than observing when it is formed. But if you're proposing to use an EEG to measure electricity in a computer and calling that consciousness, I'm sorry but you're way out to lunch. Is that what you are saying here? You can measure a computer's consciousness with an EEG?
I think it requires biology. Don't take just my word for it. Here's some smart AI ethics dude writing in the New York Times 2 days ago:
... consciousness requires features that current A.I. systems lack, like the electrochemical activity of biological tissue.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/01/opinion/ai-consciousness-ethics.html
@wildgrass saidThat opinion article is behind a paywall and it is titled “Could AI Be Conscious? It’s Definitely Possible” and you’re claiming impossibility.
Philosophically, you can only be confident about the existence of your own consciousness. That's because human brains give rise to the experience of consciousness. "Je pense donc je suis." And yet, practically, obviously, there are tools to measure consciousness. You mention EEG.
It appears to be measurable. Science measures it most reliably when it goes away, rather tha ...[text shortened]... biological tissue.[/quote]
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/01/opinion/ai-consciousness-ethics.html
Your quote is half of one sentence. For all I know the start of that sentence was “A commonly believed but fallacious idea is that…”
Despite your claims of advanced scientific education your posts are extremely vague, lack any evidence and appear to be based on faith.
@wildgrass saidI found the article and this is how that sentence starts:
Philosophically, you can only be confident about the existence of your own consciousness. That's because human brains give rise to the experience of consciousness. "Je pense donc je suis." And yet, practically, obviously, there are tools to measure consciousness. You mention EEG.
It appears to be measurable. Science measures it most reliably when it goes away, rather tha ...[text shortened]... biological tissue.[/quote]
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/01/opinion/ai-consciousness-ethics.html
https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/technology/artificial-intelligence/could-ai-be-conscious-its-definitely-possible-4201911
Even if current AI systems are not conscious, future systems might be. Suppose the skeptics are right that consciousness requires features that current AI systems lack, like the electrochemical activity of biological tissue.
Very disingenuous of you to cut off the beginning and context of that sentence.
Interestingly there is no author listed so I could not check if he really was a “smart AI ethics dude” as you claim. I don’t know how you determined his qualifications.
@AThousandYoung saidFaith is what the tech world has used to anthropomorphize their computers. Indeed, it seems you have assumed that consciousness can be artificially created by injecting a computer with human thoughts, but that's not how consciousness is formed and I don't think that'll work. Regarding the possibility at some future point, I will not rule that out. It's the prevailing methodology that make it impossible.
That opinion article is behind a paywall and it it titled “Could AI Be Conscious? It’s Definitely Possible” and you’re claiming impossibility.
Your quote is half of one sentence. For all I know the start of that sentence was “A commonly believed but fallacious idea is that…”
Despite your claims of advanced scientific education your posts are extremely vague, lack any evidence and appear to be based on faith.
We've used the birds vs. planes analogy in this thread. You can create a plane that can fly way faster than a bird, but that does not mean that it has developed feelings. I think that's an approximate quote from one of Yuval Harari's books.
@AThousandYoung saidDisingenuous? Please. I sourced and quoted.
I found the article and this is how that sentence starts:
[quote]https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/technology/artificial-intelligence/could-ai-be-conscious-its-definitely-possible-4201911
Even if current AI systems are not conscious, future systems might be. Suppose the skeptics are right that consciousness requires features that current AI systems la ...[text shortened]... ally was a “smart AI ethics dude” as you claim. I don’t know how you determined his qualifications.
It is you who assumes that consciousness can exist outside of biological systems. This is a leap of faith and a departure from reality.
@wildgrass saidWhat do feelings have to do with flying?
Faith is what the tech world has used to anthropomorphize their computers. Indeed, it seems you have assumed that consciousness can be artificially created by injecting a computer with human thoughts, but that's not how consciousness is formed and I don't think that'll work. Regarding the possibility at some future point, I will not rule that out. It's the prevailing method ...[text shortened]... hat it has developed feelings. I think that's an approximate quote from one of Yuval Harari's books.
People, including well educated people, used to assume only living things could fly because only living things had been observed to fly. For example,
Lord Kelvin, 1895
I can state flatly that heavier than air flying machines are impossible.
This belief was not based on any solid reasoning and was eventually proved wrong.
That is how a bird analogy applies to this. I don't know why you brought feelings into that analogy.
@wildgrass saidYou misquoted deliberately leaving out half the sentence to distort the intended meaning.
Disingenuous? Please. I sourced and quoted.
It is you who assumes that consciousness can exist outside of biological systems. This is a leap of faith and a departure from reality.
That writer does not believe what you claim he believes.
@AThousandYoung saidConsciousness is a feeling.
What do feelings have to do with flying?
People, including well educated people, used to assume only living things could fly because only living things had been observed to fly. For example,Lord Kelvin, 1895
I can state flatly that heavier than air flying machines are impossible.
This belief was not based on any solid reasoning and was event ...[text shortened]... hat is how a bird analogy applies to this. I don't know why you brought feelings into that analogy.
@wildgrass saidThat's not a standard definition of the word. Consciousness is awareness of one's own self, including feelings. A person can be aware of feeling nothing and still be conscious.
Consciousness is a feeling.
Your definition isn't the normal one.
@wildgrass saidI have assumed nothing and I have no idea what it would mean to "inject a computer with thoughts".
Faith is what the tech world has used to anthropomorphize their computers. Indeed, it seems you have assumed that consciousness can be artificially created by injecting a computer with human thoughts, but that's not how consciousness is formed and I don't think that'll work. Regarding the possibility at some future point, I will not rule that out. It's the prevailing method ...[text shortened]... hat it has developed feelings. I think that's an approximate quote from one of Yuval Harari's books.
A self-modifying set of complex electrical discharges controlled by software would be the most likely way of developing artificial consciousness in my opinion. I don't see any reason it would need "biological" elements though how you define "biological" I'm not sure. You COULD call wires "biological" because they have a similar function to nerves. I don't know where you draw the line.
See that's a scientific description. It involves observable, well defined concepts like electrical voltages, complex patterns with high information content etc.
"Injecting a machine with thoughts" is poetry and is meaningless in this context.
1 edit
@AThousandYoung saidSemantic gobbledygook. Consciousness as awareness and awareness as the ability to recognize feelings.
That's not a standard definition of the word. Consciousness is awareness of one's own self, including feelings. A person can be aware of feeling nothing and still be conscious.
Your definition isn't the normal one.
It seems like an unneeded thought experiment. Consciousness in the absence of feeling would mean you were only conscious of your own existence, and there would be no reference input stimulus. A brain in a vat. I've no idea if this would be possible.
@AThousandYoung saidNerves as wires is a useful analogy but in reality the biological systems operate with chemical gradients and synaptic exchange of proteins, which happen to involve charged molecules as a consequence of that. The currents in nerves flow mechanically, not electrically. When memories are formed, the neurons will change shape, size, structure, protein content, DNA organization. When memories are accessed, they change shape again, and the memory itself also changes form.
I have assumed nothing and I have no idea what it would mean to "inject a computer with thoughts".
A self-modifying set of complex electrical discharges controlled by software would be the most likely way of developing artificial consciousness in my opinion. I don't see any reason it would need "biological" elements though how you define "biological" I'm not sure. ...[text shortened]... on content etc.
"Injecting a machine with thoughts" is poetry and is meaningless in this context.
One of the worst analogies out there is the comparison of a brain to a computer. We don't know all completely how it works other than that it works completely differently from how a computer works.
@wildgrass saidNormally perceptions and opinions are not considered "feelings" either. You're using that word awfully loosely to the point of meaninglessness.
Semantic gobbledygook. Consciousness as awareness and awareness as the ability to recognize feelings.
It seems like an unneeded thought experiment. Consciousness in the absence of feeling would mean you were only conscious of your own existence, and there would be no reference input stimulus. A brain in a vat. I've no idea if this would be possible.
"How are you feeling Johnny?"
"I'm feeling blue"
"Aww why is that Johnny?"
"Because my eyes are pointed at the sky and blue light is entering them and stimulating my retina so I am feeling the blueness"
????
@wildgrass saidSo what's a better analogy for the brain?
Nerves as wires is a useful analogy but in reality the biological systems operate with chemical gradients and synaptic exchange of proteins, which happen to involve charged molecules as a consequence of that. The currents in nerves flow mechanically, not electrically. When memories are formed, the neurons will change shape, size, structure, protein content, DNA organization ...[text shortened]... l completely how it works other than that it works completely differently from how a computer works.
I don't know what you mean by current flowing mechanically not electrically. Electrical current in wires is caused by the physical mechanical movement of charged particles called electrons. I guess you're differentiating between the movement of ions vs movement of electrons? Odd way to describe it.