Go back
Kanter Freedom can't play with the girls? But Lia Thomas (male) got to??

Kanter Freedom can't play with the girls? But Lia Thomas (male) got to??

Debates


@no1marauder said
Both you and Joe ignored this post:

""The 34-year-old [Kantner] explained his side of the story on the incident with Cloud, while stating he had been at the game in support of Sophie Cunningham - who has taken a stance against trans athletes playing in the WNBA.

https://www.themirror.com/sport/basketball/enes-kanter-freedom-wnba-gender-1996151

Kantner's pl ...[text shortened]... ransgender women. Not even you are so stupid as to not know this (Joe might be that stupid perhaps).
question...is Lia Thomas a man or woman? Is Bruce/kaitlin Jenner a man or woman?


@Mott-The-Hoople said
question...is Lia Thomas a man or woman? Is Bruce/kaitlin Jenner a man or woman?
They're both women AFAIK.


@Mott-The-Hoople said
Who showed their argument was frivolous or bad faith?
How can you be so obtuse?


@Suzianne said
Did you watch it?
I checked the title....What is a Woman.
On the Forum, we explore each other's thinking. I want to know how people like yourself think they are entitled to the labor of others, for instance. What if you sent me a post of someone, like a youtube, that gives THEIR opinion, which I did not ask for.
Say Shav says Trump murders people. He then follows with a Steven Colbert youtube calling war deaths 'murder'. Suzianne...I asked SHAV what HE thinks. I know Colbert...I wold no even KNOW the creator of your youtube. Copuld be an Iranian whose brother was 'murdered' in Iran. Not very credible, n'est-ce pas??

But to comment on your issue, I know what a woman is, so would hardly watch it,...I would not want my adoration of women to be tainted by slime.


@Suzianne said
I am discussing facts.

This is how you are ruining America.
It would be wonderful if you would change your discussion methods to facts. And posts with a beginning, a middle and an end. And not about what other people think or You Tube.
Like how we are ruining America. I would LOVE for anyone to show me that, as his accomplishment list is astounding.
Posts are also nice if screaming is left to a minimum.


@AverageJoe1 said
I checked the title....What is a Woman.
On the Forum, we explore each other's thinking. I want to know how people like yourself think they are entitled to the labor of others, for instance. What if you sent me a post of someone, like a youtube, that gives THEIR opinion, which I did not ask for.
Say Shav says Trump murders people. He then follows with a Steven ...[text shortened]... oman is, so would hardly watch it,...I would not want my adoration of women to be tainted by slime.
AJoe1: I would not want my adoration of women to be tainted by slime.

Exactly. Joe. And it is an afront to men, as well. Attention getters, iz'all 😉


@Earl-of-Trumps said
AJoe1: I would not want my adoration of women to be tainted by slime.

Exactly. Joe. And it is an afront to men, as well. Attention getters, iz'all 😉
Hilarious.

The only ones paying a grossly disproportionate amount of attention to transgender people are right wing politicians, their propaganda networks and gullible fools like AJ.


@no1marauder said
Hilarious.

The only ones paying a grossly disproportionate amount of attention to transgender people are right wing politicians, their propaganda networks and gullible fools like AJ.
There you are. I thought you may be that holdout juror in Clancy! It would figure. A contrarian in he jury room . Oh, great


@no1marauder said
Hilarious.

The only ones paying a grossly disproportionate amount of attention to transgender people are right wing politicians, their propaganda networks and gullible fools like AJ.
And the women they are harming

1 edit

@no1marauder said
They're both women AFAIK.
That’s weird…Jenner doesn’t consider themself a woman.

“Caitlyn Jenner: Transgender Women Aren't Really Women
One of the world's most famous transgender people said she doesn't consider herself a woman but is instead a "trans person." She also condemned trans women's inclusion in women's sports.”


https://www.advocate.com/transgender/caitlyn-jenner-trans-not-women

Only a fool thinks one can change their sex



Lia Thomas…

Same qualifications as Kanter freedom…why do you claim one is and one isn’t?


“Lia is not, nor ever will be, a woman. Lia can refer to Lia in any particular way Lia wants. Lia can dress however Lia wants. Lia can identify however Lia wants. But Lia has male genitalia. Lia does not have breasts. Lia cannot bear children or produce eggs. Lia does not have a menstrual cycle. Lia will never go through menopause. These are the biological norms for being a woman. These are facts. This is science. And, as we all know from the past two years, science must be trusted.“



Mhttps://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/2878198/no-lia-thomas-is-not-a-woman/


@wildgrass said
How can you be so obtuse?
Answer the question


@Mott-The-Hoople said
That’s weird…Jenner doesn’t consider themself a woman.

“Caitlyn Jenner: Transgender Women Aren't Really Women
One of the world's most famous transgender people said she doesn't consider herself a woman but is instead a "trans person." She also condemned trans women's inclusion in women's sports.”


https://www.advocate.com/transgender/caitlyn-jenner-trans-not-women

Only a fool thinks one can change their sex
Look at you tying yourself in logical knots over this.

Caitlyn Jenner isn't a woman because she doesn't consider themself to be one? Hmm, it's almost like Caltlyn is self-identifying.


@Mott-The-Hoople said
Answer the question
Your argument is in bad faith because you've chosen an issue that doesn't exist and staked your position that it does exist. Kanter Freedom isn't eligible to play in the WNBA, this has been stated unequivocally by the leaders of that organization. You keep insisting that he is. Moreover, there are no other examples of any male athlete who is playing or has ever played in the WNBA. It's a classic strawman logical fallacy.


@AverageJoe1 said
It would be wonderful if you would change your discussion methods to facts. And posts with a beginning, a middle and an end. And not about what other people think or You Tube.
Like how we are ruining America. I would LOVE for anyone to show me that, as his accomplishment list is astounding.
Posts are also nice if screaming is left to a minimum.
There was that movie about a man who decided to cross-dress and play on a women's basketball team because there was a girl on that team that he liked?

Juwanna Mann.

Maybe that's what you all are talking about in terms of "facts" here? The plot of a fictional movie?


@Mott-The-Hoople said
That’s weird…Jenner doesn’t consider themself a woman.

“Caitlyn Jenner: Transgender Women Aren't Really Women
One of the world's most famous transgender people said she doesn't consider herself a woman but is instead a "trans person." She also condemned trans women's inclusion in women's sports.”


https://www.advocate.com/transgender/caitlyn-jenner-trans-not-w ...[text shortened]... t be trusted.“



Mhttps://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/2878198/no-lia-thomas-is-not-a-woman/
If one of those freaks is racing my wife, who is in the middle of menopause, surely the freak will have an advantage, her energy will be depleted where the freaks's never will.
It....will beat her.