Go back
What happened to Wolfgang59?

What happened to Wolfgang59?

General

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FMF
The thumbs up and down not being anonymous would be "tyranny"? How so?
Do you ever read my posts before you bad mouth them?

"Removing free speech is always the first act of tyranny, and never the last."

In other words, I've already answered this. So your "What?" is really a bumbling fumble for something to say, like usual. You really do need some new tricks. The interrogation routine is getting old.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FMF
Is there something specific that you are currently very, very angry about or is your anger today simply generic ? 😛
No, not at all. Why?

Unless, of course, it is a few individuals trying to express their opinions as if they had "the divine right of kings" upon them.


Originally posted by Suzianne
No, not at all. Why?

Unless, of course, it is a few individuals trying to express their opinions as if they had "the divine right of kings" upon them.
What are you on about? Everyone here has the same right to express their opinions. "Divine right of kings"? What is it you're on about?



Originally posted by Suzianne
Do you ever read my posts before you bad mouth them?

"Removing free speech is always the first act of tyranny, and never the last."

In other words, I've already answered this. So your "What?" is really a bumbling fumble for something to say, like usual. You really do need some new tricks. The interrogation routine is getting old.
How can the thumbs up and down not being anonymous be characterized as "Removing free speech"? People would still be able to say what they want and would still be able to thumb up or thumb down whatever they want. How would their freedom be curtailed in any way?

1 edit

Originally posted by FMF
How can the thumbs up and down not being anonymous be characterized as "Removing free speech"? People would still be able to say what they want and would still be able to thumb up or thumb down whatever they want. How would their freedom be curtailed in any way?
Do you vote in elections? Would you think your vote would be as safe, or even as truly freely made, if it were not made by secret ballot?

How might you vote differently, if your voting record were made public knowledge?

(I know this might seem bizarre for you, but try to think about the question before shooting from the hip.)

Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
Yes, but they were not intended to be used by people trying to bend the will of those reading to their own ends.


Originally posted by Suzianne
How might you vote differently, if your voting record were made public knowledge?
I don't see why I would vote differently. I can't think of a reason why I would vote differently. Would you? You still haven't addressed the question: 'How can the thumbs up and down not being anonymous be characterized as "Removing free speech"?' If thumbs up and down were no longer anonymous, you could still use them, still not use them, you could still say whatever you want, or not say whatever you don't want to say, you could keep your feelings and opinions secret, or you could tell people about them; your freedom of speech would be unaffected.



Originally posted by Suzianne
Do you vote in elections? Would you think your vote would be as safe, or even as truly freely made, if it were not made by secret ballot?
I haven't voted in an election for a long time.

Are there times when you thumb posts down and it's important to you that nobody knows it was you?


How about an added feature to the thumbs such that you could thumb as anon or non-anon?


Originally posted by wolfgang59
How about an added feature to the thumbs such that you could thumb as anon or non-anon?
That's the dumbest idea I have ever heard.
Who conjured your ass back to the site?


Originally posted by FreakyKBH
That's the dumbest idea I have ever heard.
Who conjured your ass back to the site?
When the previous "dumbest idea you had ever heard" was the Globe Earth Theory I'm not really concerned.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by wolfgang59
When the previous "dumbest idea you had ever heard" was the Globe Earth Theory I'm not really concerned.
You have a point.
But...
if you part your hair just so, no one will even notice it.


Originally posted by Suzianne
Removing free speech is always the first act of tyranny, and never the last. If you remove the anonymity of the thumbs, you may as well remove the thumbs entirely.
Are there ever times when you thumb a post down and it's important to you that nobody knows it was you?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.