Go back
Question or Suggestion

Question or Suggestion

Site Ideas

jmwinrider

Joined
22 Sep 10
Moves
447731
Clock
06 Mar 21

Please forgive me if this is spoken in ignorance, or is an already considered change but.... It would be nice if I had some way to see how many more vacation days an opponent has left. I sometimes have games against opponents who seem to use the vacation flag an awful lot and for long periods of time (while continuing to play some of their games ... just not mine). It would be easier to be patient with them or decide to resign the games if I knew how much vacation they had left for the year. So far I've not figured out how to determine this.

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
669930
Clock
16 Apr 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

@jmwinrider said
Please forgive me if this is spoken in ignorance, or is an already considered change but.... It would be nice if I had some way to see how many more vacation days an opponent has left. I sometimes have games against opponents who seem to use the vacation flag an awful lot and for long periods of time (while continuing to play some of their games ... just not mine). It wo ...[text shortened]... ew how much vacation they had left for the year. So far I've not figured out how to determine this.
As yet there is no way.

I support the suggestion however.

venda
Dave

S.Yorks.England

Joined
18 Apr 10
Moves
86176
Clock
16 Apr 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

@jmwinrider said
Please forgive me if this is spoken in ignorance, or is an already considered change but.... It would be nice if I had some way to see how many more vacation days an opponent has left. I sometimes have games against opponents who seem to use the vacation flag an awful lot and for long periods of time (while continuing to play some of their games ... just not mine). It wo ...[text shortened]... ew how much vacation they had left for the year. So far I've not figured out how to determine this.
It has been suggested in the past but not implemented.
I also agree it could be useful.
Looks like Russ is really busy with other stuff and it would be low priority I would think.

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
669930
Clock
22 Apr 21
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@venda said
It has been suggested in the past but not implemented.
I also agree it could be useful.
Looks like Russ is really busy with other stuff and it would be low priority I would think.
Well he did some changes quickly in the past, if it was easy to implement.

Russ
RHP Code Monkey

RHP HQ

Joined
21 Feb 01
Moves
2450
Clock
22 Apr 21
1 edit

The vacation days remaining was considered potentially sensitive data to be public when the vacation system was built. I suspect this was never the case, so I will message all subs, and if no one objects, I'll make the data public on a player's profile.

tombeatenbaugh

Atlanta, Ga. USA

Joined
24 Dec 10
Moves
208642
Clock
23 Apr 21

The internet is everywhere.. Vacation days are used to slow down games. Vacationers pick and choose the games they move in. If you use vacation time you shouldn't be allowed to move in any of your games. 36 days is excessive. To answer the question YES it should be public.

tharg
Tharg The Mighty

Betelgeuse

Joined
22 Feb 02
Moves
155019
Clock
23 Apr 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

tharg
Tharg The Mighty

Betelgeuse

Joined
22 Feb 02
Moves
155019
Clock
23 Apr 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

@tombeatenbaugh said
The internet is everywhere.. Vacation days are used to slow down games. Vacationers pick and choose the games they move in. If you use vacation time you shouldn't be allowed to move in any of your games. 36 days is excessive. To answer the question YES it should be public.
Absolutely agree on this idea. Vacation days are not free timebank.

Russ
RHP Code Monkey

RHP HQ

Joined
21 Feb 01
Moves
2450
Clock
23 Apr 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

@tombeatenbaugh said
The internet is everywhere.. Vacation days are used to slow down games. Vacationers pick and choose the games they move in. If you use vacation time you shouldn't be allowed to move in any of your games. 36 days is excessive. To answer the question YES it should be public.
Although this is a separate issue to the one under discussion, I agree, and believe 21 days max would have even been more suitable back when the vacation system was introduced. 36 was, and now definitely is, too much.

Two spin-off discussions (which could be put to a vote for all subscribers) -

- Reduction of vacation days.*
- Prevent moves being made when vacation flag is up. This one is obviously the most contentious, but if an overwhelming majority of subscribers agree, I'm happy to implement it.

* Any change to vacation days could only happen at year end (start of 2022)

R
Standard memberRemoved

Joined
07 Jan 11
Moves
59592
Clock
23 Apr 21

@Russ I agree with all the suggestions. Less days, make days left visible, no moves while flag is up.

SRB

Joined
03 Apr 19
Moves
25268
Clock
23 Apr 21
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@Russ

No travelling recently due to COVID, but I would like to be able to vacation where the internet isn't sometimes without having to lose all my existing games. It's a good feature that shouldn't be got rid of just because people abuse it.

Loads of people on this site do the thing where they don't move for the max. possible time in clearly losing positions so you have to learn to just be with that. I sometimes make notes of my ideas now in anticipation.

Edit: totally agree with no moving while flag is up.

orangutan
ook

hirsute rooster

Joined
13 Apr 05
Moves
20607
Clock
23 Apr 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

@russ said
Although this is a separate issue to the one under discussion, I agree, and believe 21 days max would have even been more suitable back when the vacation system was introduced. 36 was, and now definitely is, too much.

Two spin-off discussions (which could be put to a vote for all subscribers) -

- Reduction of vacation days.*
- Prevent moves being made when vacation flag ...[text shortened]... appy to implement it.

* Any change to vacation days could only happen at year end (start of 2022)
As has been said - the internet is everywhere, so reducing the number of days available shouldn't be a problem.
Even if you reduce it to 21 - over the new year you could end up with 42 days immunity.

If you're taking a break away from the games you have going - then you should take a break. Not allowing your opponent the timeout option but still allowing you to move when on "vacation" has always seemed unfair.

So, yes reduce the number of days for vacation and when the flag is up - block moves as well. This needs to be done in a way that doesn't allow for quickly going off holiday to make a move then straight back on vacation again.

l

Victor, New York

Joined
08 May 09
Moves
2037265
Clock
23 Apr 21

I have a different opinion. I use the vacation time when I am on vacation or in a place where I might not have the time or inclination to keep all of my games current. (Also, even though the internet seems to be everywhere, it’s not effectively that way. Think cruise ships where internet is an additional charge.) when I use vacation, I like to make moves if I can so that I don’t lose valuable time out. I consider vacation time my “play if you want, don’t play if you don’t”.

I have no objection to making total vacation time public but don’t you really want to know how much longer the current vacation flag is?

As for the other issues, 36 days is fine with me. 21 is a little short (I’m retired and used to vacation a lot.) I want to be able to move during vacation time due to the number of games I carry. Would the restriction on moves also restrict my actions as a club and clan leader?

Homer1Simpson
The REAL UK Homer 😁

Here, obviously!

Joined
23 Jan 10
Moves
163025
Clock
23 Apr 21
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@tombeatenbaugh said
The internet is everywhere.. Vacation days are used to slow down games. Vacationers pick and choose the games they move in. If you use vacation time you shouldn't be allowed to move in any of your games. 36 days is excessive. To answer the question YES it should be public.
Whenever I've used my vacation days, it's ALWAYS applied to all my games as it should. To use vacation days as a way of slowing down a particular game/s is despicable and and is a form of cheating. Therefore, when a player uses their vacation days it should apply to ALL of their games, surely?

Erika Nu

Utrecht Netherlands

Joined
07 May 17
Moves
13956
Clock
23 Apr 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

I guess that it is an excellent idea.

Whenever I take time off, this would disturb the flow for my opponent.

Since it is in the end the two of us that are 'colleagues' in the game, I believe that it is more than fair to inform him of my time off.

So totally subscribing to the idea of making it public.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.