13 Aug '08 21:27>1 edit
It has made tournaments and clan matches into a seemingly never ending ordeal if one player chooses to delay. For example, this 3/7 tournament started on September 28, 2007 http://www.timeforchess.com/tournament/view.php?tid=2705
There is only one game remaining: http://www.timeforchess.com/gameanalysis/boardhistory.php?gameid=4731753
Naturally, one of the players is on "vacation". Just as naturally, he is continuing to move in most of his 50 games. But he insists on dragging out his one remaining game in the tourney. It seems quite likely that it will require a year to finish the first round of a 3/7 tourney. Since there will be at least two more rounds in this tourney, it seems highly probable that because of the vacation system it will require over two years to complete a tournament with 3/7 time controls all due to the machinations of a few sluggards. This is ridiculous.
I also have a clan game going where a player is on "vacation" but is moving in virtually all of his 240 games. His time has expired but through strategic use of his vacation flag he is avoiding the time out.
I would prefer the voluntary vacation system that used to be in place, but if there is going to be a mandatory one at least forbid players from making moves in any games or losing the protection of the vacation. If you're on vacation, you're on vacation; it should not be used for the gamesmanship of not moving in some games to avoid losses while moving in virtually all of your other games. And the vacation flag should not protect you at all in tournament games IMO; it is too much of an inconvenience for the vast majority of other players.
Thoughts?
There is only one game remaining: http://www.timeforchess.com/gameanalysis/boardhistory.php?gameid=4731753
Naturally, one of the players is on "vacation". Just as naturally, he is continuing to move in most of his 50 games. But he insists on dragging out his one remaining game in the tourney. It seems quite likely that it will require a year to finish the first round of a 3/7 tourney. Since there will be at least two more rounds in this tourney, it seems highly probable that because of the vacation system it will require over two years to complete a tournament with 3/7 time controls all due to the machinations of a few sluggards. This is ridiculous.
I also have a clan game going where a player is on "vacation" but is moving in virtually all of his 240 games. His time has expired but through strategic use of his vacation flag he is avoiding the time out.
I would prefer the voluntary vacation system that used to be in place, but if there is going to be a mandatory one at least forbid players from making moves in any games or losing the protection of the vacation. If you're on vacation, you're on vacation; it should not be used for the gamesmanship of not moving in some games to avoid losses while moving in virtually all of your other games. And the vacation flag should not protect you at all in tournament games IMO; it is too much of an inconvenience for the vast majority of other players.
Thoughts?