Originally posted by John W Booth
You are a hypocrite. On the Debates Forum you frequently argue that the U.S. should pull out of Afghanistan and leave the Taliban to it. And here you are trying to browbeat robbie about it.
No, what I am saying is that as a soldier you have orders to follow to accomplish a certain task even if you do not understand or may disagree with that task. We all encounter this dilemma no matter your job, however, that does not mean that you turn off your conscience when you feel as though you are violating your own inner moral compass. For example, you are sent to Afghanistan to attack those who are at war with you, namely Al Qaeda. You know that if you are not fighting them here, they will try and find a way to fight you elsewhere. You may not agree with the tactics in particular battles nor may you agree with the presence of American troops in Afghanistan, but you are sent to do a job in good conscience. However, if that commander asks you to kill innocent civilians, for example, you may decline and not carry out those orders because they are not the law breakers your are after.
As for myself, I understand that the US has an enemy in Al Qaeda and nothing will ever change that. They will seek to kill Americans abroad no matter what the US does and if those soldiers were not there millions would die. However, that does not mean that I agree with the tactics they are using currently in Afghanistan. In short, there is nothing really to accomplish there other than try to set up a government in Afghanistan that opposes your enemies. If South Korea is any indication, that will mean troops will stay there indefinately and I just don't see that it is worth the cost.