Go back
Creation vs. Evolution

Creation vs. Evolution

Spirituality

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sargent Carpface
Ha YOU CRIMINAL, KELLY HAS 2 USER NAMES. YOU SHOULD STOP SIGNING YOUR NAME IF YOU DONT WANNA GET CAUGHT!
You saw the quotes?
Kelly

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by twhitehead
I agree that one can never be absolutely sure of anything just as you cannot be absolutely sure that yesterday really happened. God or some other entity could have planted the memories in your head. But it therefore follows that we can never know the history of any device so even that requirement is useless to us. After all how will you know the history o ...[text shortened]... r reasons but I do have a problem if you say the evidence is not there - that would be lying.
"However here in the real world we can be sure of something without being absolutely sure. We can also talk about 'reasonable explanations'. For example that a green alien planted yesterdays memories in your head is not a reasonable explanation. That yesterday really happened is.

Do you agree so far?"

I agree so far.

"When we talk about things that appear to be a certain age, then there are many explanations, one could be that it truly is that age, the other could be that a green alien or God faked it. Which is a reasonable explanation?"

I do not believe God faked anything, things are what they are, and
you could be right about the age of the universe, I have acknowledge
that from day one. I have never said that you are not trying to be
reasonable when dating, I have said and I still maintain you are
indeed making a leap of faith when you do!

"OK, please answer this question honestly:
Do you accept that all the scientific evidence available indicates that the earth is millions of years old (whether it truly is or isn't)?"

I can see how you'd come to that conclusion I always have, but as I
have pointed out it must be accepted on faith.
Kelly

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by serigado
OH.. and for Kelly and all those that think Carbon Dating is wrong... For the age of the earth being calculated to be ~4.5 billion years old IS NOT used carbon dating. Carbon dating is not very precise for such huge time.
There are many different methods to calculate it, and they ALL match.
So, there are 2 hypothesis.
1- Your faith based system is right ...[text shortened]... reality.
It's not a 100% certain, but it is 99.99999(9)%: the earth is OLDER then 6000 years.
If I'm not mistaken and I could be, I believe carbon is thought to be
very acturate up to 7K years and after that you must build in the
possibility of error, and the older something is deated the greater the
error that is possible.

I believe you should stick to those things you know when you post,
since your mind reading abilities are a little off.
Kelly

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KellyJay
If I'm not mistaken and I could be, I believe carbon is thought to be
very acturate up to 7K years and after that you must build in the
possibility of error, and the older something is deated the greater the
error that is possible.

I believe you should stick to those things you know when you post,
since your mind reading abilities are a little off.
Kelly
I know quite well what I write. Carbon is accurate up to 10-20K years. New methods make it accurate with error around 20% to 100000 years. It means it may have something between 80K and 120K years. Even within error, it's older then all your assumptions..
BUt there are other methods.
Why do you try to discredit me saying something like "I should stick blablabla". I know what I talk about. Very clearly. You don't, and you didn't answer me nor provided any arguments. I'm waiting.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by twhitehead
Do you also find it amusing that scientists believe that stars came about via natural causes but have not yet duplicated the creation of a star?
And while were at it, how many mountains, have scientists made recently?
50 years ago you would have been amused that no one had succeeded in making something as simple as a diamond. Do you think that diamonds ...[text shortened]... money on the effort that they are wasting their time, whodey knows better, only God can do it.
For me the existence of both matter and life are unexplicable. Therefore, the creation of either would be monumental to say the least.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
Curses, foiled again! If it weren't for you meddling kids...
Ha ha very funny you must be a comadien. (THAT WAS SPELT WRONG ON PURPOSE.) Well you obviously dont apply to the no making 2 accounts rule. How many more do you have? You hipocrit. You told me not to make more than 1 and I didn;t. and wrong. im 13. not a kid. Jerk.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KellyJay
You saw the quotes?
Kelly
Yeah,

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sargent Carpface
Ha ha very funny you must be a comadien. (THAT WAS SPELT WRONG ON PURPOSE.) Well you obviously dont apply to the no making 2 accounts rule. How many more do you have? You hipocrit. You told me not to make more than 1 and I didn;t. and wrong. im 13. not a kid. Jerk.
13's a kid dickhead. Get over it.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by amannion
13's a kid dickhead. Get over it.
Fine I perfer to think of it as a teen, I dont like to be called a "kid" dipwad. Besides I am 5 foot 8, (SERIOUSLY) It felt wierd to be called just a "KID" now that im 13 I can get out of that stage. Call me a teen or at least a name other than (KID or Child). It can have profanity if you want and you feel a need. But the spys on this website might object. Just call me an idiot cretin, etc.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sargent Carpface
Fine I perfer to think of it as a teen, I dont like to be called a "kid" dipwad. Besides I am 5 foot 8, (SERIOUSLY) It felt wierd to be called just a "KID" now that im 13 I can get out of that stage. Call me a teen or at least a name other than (KID or Child). It can have profanity if you want and you feel a need. But the spys on this website might object. Just call me an idiot cretin, etc.
There are many things in this life we don't like.
For example, I don't like half-educated idiots that claim to have all the answers to life's questions, but clearly know nothing.
But hey, what are you gonna do?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by amannion
There are many things in this life we don't like.
For example, I don't like half-educated idiots that claim to have all the answers to life's questions, but clearly know nothing.
But hey, what are you gonna do?
Thanks for not calling me a kid and no I dont know the ALL the answers But Still I do know that DNA or genes can only get lower or stay the same. If we were from cave men. who came from apes. Our DNA would stay the same and our IQ would be so low you cant test it you have to dig for it.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sargent Carpface
Thanks for not calling me a kid and no I dont know the ALL the answers But Still I do know that DNA or genes can only get lower or stay the same. If we were from cave men. who came from apes. Our DNA would stay the same and our IQ would be so low you cant test it you have to dig for it.
You know nothing about DNA or genes.
Your written statements don't make sense.

DNA can only get lower? What does that mean.
I'm a science teacher and so have a bit of a working knowledge of this stuff and I have no idea what you're talking about. Most of your sentences are meaningless.
Try this: stick with one thought at a time and carefully type it out.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by amannion
You know nothing about DNA or genes.
Your written statements don't make sense.

DNA can only get lower? What does that mean.
I'm a science teacher and so have a bit of a working knowledge of this stuff and I have no idea what you're talking about. Most of your sentences are meaningless.
Try this: stick with one thought at a time and carefully type it out.
Gotcha I have to go to the library before it closes ill get back to ya/

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sargent Carpface
Thanks for not calling me a kid and no I dont know the ALL the answers But Still I do know that DNA or genes can only get lower or stay the same. If we were from cave men. who came from apes. Our DNA would stay the same and our IQ would be so low you cant test it you have to dig for it.
You've been told that by ID proponents. It's a common tactic of theirs. Do you understand DNA enough to say why? They'll tell you that no "new information" can be added. The problem is that, depending on the proponent, they either do not understand how mutations and/or information theory works or they distort it for their own aims.

I know the sort of training you've had. As I shared before, I too was schooled in creationism*. I would be careful about claiming to know anything about life or physical science. Be prepared -- no, be excited! -- for a trained biologist to take the time to teach you something new.

Good luck.

* - I would have learned ID then too, but the Supreme Court hadn't yet made it necessary for that pseudonym at that point.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sargent Carpface
Ha ha very funny you must be a comadien. (THAT WAS SPELT WRONG ON PURPOSE.) Well you obviously dont apply to the no making 2 accounts rule. How many more do you have? You hipocrit. You told me not to make more than 1 and I didn;t. and wrong. im 13. not a kid. Jerk.
Read these words, I told you not to do the 2nd account it isn't a rule
it would be thought of as deceptive. You are barking up the wrong
tree by thinking I have two accounts. Look at our history, our chess
games, our conversations, how we write, we are not the same person.
Kelly