Originally posted by twhitehead
And that is the key that I want answers to, and that nobody will answer. Who am I? What defines me? And what gives you the confidence that you know who I am and what defines me? Are you sure it is what I think is who I am and what defines me? Do I really care what happens to the 'me' that you think will stay on after my death?
You haven't even begun to address these issues.
Like I have said. You understand enough to argue against it.
What defines me?
Your spirit which needs to be born again in regeneration if you are not a Christian.
Your soul,
And your physical body.
So
First Thesselonians 5:23 speaks of complete sanctification as being of
"spirit and soul and body".
"And the God of peace Himself sanctify you wholly, and may your spirit and soul and body be preserved complete, without blame, at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ."
At least we know that human beings are composed of
"spirit and soul and body".
The three are to be united together and not separated.
To exist with a separation of the soul from the body is abnormal.
Nevertheless it does occur at physical death. For the soul to be separated from the body is YOU but incomplete.
There is something else which is incomplete. That is to have soul and body together yet the human spirit is in a comatose and deadened state. This is to be unregenerated and is also an incompleteness of the humanity.
The human spirit is damaged, deadened, in a comatose state and therefore Christ comes that the human spirit would be enlivened - born of God.
The YOU in its most normal state is spirit (not deadened but made alive) and soul and body together.
If I hit your body and you say "Hey, do not hit me!" I cannot excuse myself by saying "But I did not hit YOU I hit just your body." You might respond that to hit your body was to hit YOU. So stop.
Your
soul is you.
You
body is you too.
And your human
spirit - the highest and deepest component of your being - is also you. And the three are to not be separated but be united.
Are you sure it is what I think is who I am and what defines me?
I am sure that you are
"spirit and soul and body".
Do I really care what happens to the 'me' that you think will stay on after my death?
I don't know if you care. I care.
You haven't even begun to address these issues
This translates to me to - "You haven't yet forced me to believe as you do."
Now I will briefly look at one question you have about this and
John 3:16.