Originally posted by KellyJay
For those that do not believe in God feel free to give what you think would
be important if God were real.
If God were real, and is to stand in judgement of us, then he should abide by the normal principles of what makes a valid justice system. In any human context, I imagine most theists would agree with the following principles, but where God is concerned they are simply overlooked.
1 The rules we are expected to abide by should be sufficiently clear that the person being judged should be able to understand whether or not they have committed an offence.
Clearly not the case, as the endless debates about abortion, gay rights etc demonstrate.
2 Any punishment should be proportionate to the crime
Clearly not the case. The punishment for minor transgressions appears to be the same as for the most heinous human rights abuses.
3 People should not be punished for what they believe (or don't).
You cannot choose what you believe. Thought crimes are the stuff of the worst excesses of a dystopia.
4 Torturing people as a punishment is unacceptable. Torturing people for all eternity is infinitely unacceptable, illogical and unnecessary.
There are lots of other things I could add to the list. But this is sufficient to demonstrate that either:
1 God is a hopeless communicator; or
2 God is evil; or
3 God does not exist.