Go back
Why are you a Christian if you don't believe the Bible?

Why are you a Christian if you don't believe the Bible?

Spirituality



-Removed-
My answer was in my post.

1 edit


-Removed-
Be clear yourself here too, are you suggesting the Bible isn't trustworthy?
Are you asking, can we be unsure about parts of it as true to the best of our understanding?
There is a difference, if you attempting to suggest we agree it isn't trustworthy, put me down
as a no, it is. If you are asking do we have to understand and accept all parts we may have
an issue with, it depends on the parts. Which would mean some things are not as
important and others and you could put me down as a yes.

1 edit

-Removed-
I think you are jumping to a conclusion.

The OP as I read it asked a question ... WHY?
I didn't see the issue being possible or not possible ... but why not trust all of the Scriptures ? Which is a perfectly valid question.

The emphasis is mine below on the OP.

If you don't believe the entire Bible is divinely inspired and is completely trustworthy in totality, ... WHY ... do you believe any of it at all?

It makes absolutely no sense to pick only the parts you like and brush the parts you don't like under the carpet and pretend that they don't exist. That is the most intellectually dishonest behavior I have ever seen. It's either all or nothing.


I don't see dj2becker's point to be other than asking the doubter to explain his rationale for his lingering mistrust in God's word.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by @velns
I don’t carry a strong opinion on this topic but I do remember you describing your all or nothing experiences in a Christian cult and I therefore find myself very surprised to see you propsosing the same cultish philosophy in your approach to the bible.
Which 'all or nothing experiences' are you specifically talking about? The cult I was a part of used to enforce rules that weren't in the Bible.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by @rajk999
Jesus Christ has the words of eternal life.
Sure and if you believe the gospel writers were divinely inspired to accurately convey those words why wouldn't the rest of the Bible also be divinely inspired? Do you believe the gospel writers were only divinely inspired while they were writing down the words of Jesus and not the rest of the time?

Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
How on earth did you reach that conclusion based on what I wrote? 🙄

Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
You seem to be totally missing the point as usual. The reason for the OP was to establish how those (who don't trust all of the Bible) know which parts to trust and which parts to distrust.


Originally posted by @dj2becker
Sure and if you believe the gospel writers were divinely inspired to accurately convey those words why wouldn't the rest of the Bible also be divinely inspired? Do you believe the gospel writers were only divinely inspired while they were writing down the words of Jesus and not the rest of the time?
You asked a question. I answered
I asked a question. You ignored it
You are asking another question.

What you you think I should do?


Originally posted by @dj2becker
You seem to be totally missing the point as usual. The reason for the OP was to establish how those (who don't trust all of the Bible) know which parts to trust and which parts to distrust.
This was answered already. Jesus said to trust him. Trust him means trusting in his words in particularly those words what lead to eternal life. Jesus words are spirit and life. They give eternal life.


Originally posted by @rajk999
This was answered already. Jesus said to trust him. Trust him means trusting in his words in particularly those words what lead to eternal life. Jesus words are spirit and life. They give eternal life.
So do you believe only the words of Jesus happen to be divinely inspired and the rest of the Bible isn't or am I missing something?


Originally posted by @rajk999
Books were removed from the Bible over the centuries. Im not talking about words changing.

Are you interested in being a bible scholar or eternal life?
Why can't I be interested in both?


Originally posted by @dj2becker
So do you believe only the words of Jesus happen to be divinely inspired and the rest of the Bible isn't or am I missing something?
Yes you are missing some brains.
All divinely inspired words do not lead to eternal life
Jesus has the words of eternal life.

1 edit

Originally posted by @rajk999
Yes you are missing some brains.
All divinely inspired words do not lead to eternal life
Jesus has the words of eternal life.
Do you reckon the words spoken by Jesus in Matthew 5:22 should be ignored? You seem to ignore them quite a lot.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.