Calling for extermination of Jews depends on context?

Three university presidents prove that all the education in the world can't fix stupid:
YouTube

You posted from a legit source. Nice.

https://abcnews.go.com/US/uproar-university-presidents-remarks-antisemitism-underscores-tensions-campuses/story?id=105502845

The question leading up to that "depends on context" remark was about students chanting "intifada". Stafanik asked whether that crosses a line into calls for genocide.

To *that" the school president said "depends on the context". That's an answer that totally makes sense.

However, Stefanik seems to have morphed the question into equating "Intifada" chants as the same as calling for genocide. I think that's where the president got tripped up.
Stefanik's line of questioning was basically "intifada" = genocide. She then asked if that breaches code of conduct. The president said "depends on context",

The president got tripped up by classic lawyering. She should've said "whether or not 'intifada' calls for genocide depends on context". It was a four-hour hearing so she may just have been too worn down by questions to think of that.

https://abcnews.go.com/US/uproar-university-presidents-remarks-antisemitism-underscores-tensions-campuses/story?id=105502845

Stefanik's question was about chants of "intifada," the Arab word for "shaking off" or "uprising," at protests on campuses.

"Does that speech not cross that barrier, does that speech not call for the genocide of Jews and the elimination of Israel?" she asked. "Is that speech according to the code of conduct or not?"

"We embrace a commitment to free expression and give a wide berth to free expression, even views that are objectionable," said Claudine Gay, the president of Harvard University.

Asked the same question, Elizabeth Magill, president of Penn, said "it is a context-dependent decision." Sally Kornbluth, the president of MIT, said it would be investigated as harassment, "if pervasive and severe."

The presidents refused to give a simple "yes" or "no" answer. Instead, they gave carefully worded responses touching on the tricky issue of free speech.

@vivify
Intifada intishmada, the question was "is calling for the genocide of Jews against your university rules" and all three hemmed and hawed and refused to say yes.

@jj-adams said
@vivify
Intifada intishmada, the question was "is calling for the genocide of Jews against your university rules" and all three hemmed and hawed and refused to say yes.

@vivify said
I agree with you. They should've just said "yes". All I'm doing is showing why they answered how they did.

The woman asking the question made a false equivalence with "intifada" chants and genocide. Those three failed to correct her and paid for it.

@vivify said
You posted from a legit source. Nice.

https://abcnews.go.com/US/uproar-university-presidents-remarks-antisemitism-underscores-tensions-campuses/story?id=105502845

The question leading up to that "depends on context" remark was about students chanting "intifada". Stafanik asked whether that crosses a line into calls for genocide.

To *that" the school president sai ...[text shortened]... . It was a four-hour hearing so she may just have been too worn down by questions to think of that.

@jj-adams said
When Hamas calls for intifada, they do mean extermination, they say so openly, regardless of whatever definition you want to put on it.

@jj-adams said
When Hamas calls for intifada, they do mean extermination, they say so openly, regardless of whatever definition you want to put on it.

@kevcvs57 said
Hey idiot intifada does not mean genocide no matter who says it. Hamas actually call for genocide but intifada means uprising and usually results in Palestinian children being shot by the IDF for throwing stones
But the three individuals have proven themselves too stupid to be running top educational establishments. The answer to the question ‘is calling for the genocide o ...[text shortened]... non violent method of genocide
But the fact is calling for an intifada is not calling for genocide

@jj-adams said
When Hamas calls for intifada, they do mean extermination, they say so openly, regardless of whatever definition you want to put on it.

@shavixmir said
Yeah? So? A bunch of criminals call a banana an apple, are you going to take their word for it?

@jj-adams said
So Hamas calls for it and they mean extermination and all the silly college students call for it but they don't know what they are calling for ...oh...screw it.

@jj-adams said
So Hamas calls for it and they mean extermination and all the silly college students call for it but they don't know what they are calling for ...oh...screw it.
Liberal doosh bag students are supporting Hamas in their demonstrations because they are idiots and stoopit college presidents are too mealy-mouthed to say genocide is bad.
Dumbash academic leftist crapheads..

@jj-adams said
So Hamas calls for it and they mean extermination and all the silly college students call for it but they don't know what they are calling for ...oh...screw it.
Liberal doosh bag students are supporting Hamas in their demonstrations because they are idiots and stoopit college presidents are too mealy-mouthed to say genocide is bad.
Dumbash academic leftist crapheads..