Go back
To everyone who voted to leave the E.U.

To everyone who voted to leave the E.U.

General


2 edits

-Removed-
I am always amused that most of my 'Remain' friends also support reform of the House of Lords, on the basis that unelected people should not have so much influence over the laws we all have to abide my.

Yet the Commission has far greater powers than the House of Lords.

The reality, I have always suspected, is that many people who support Remain simply prefer the type of politics that tend to dominate Europe.

So tacitly admitting that if they cannot achieve their means democratically, they are happy to do so undemocratically. As demonstrated by the fact that they are already agitating to ignore the referendum result.

1 edit

-Removed-
Kinnock was a bureaucrat appointed to implement democratic decisions. Equating that with what he stood for in the UK is a bit of a red herring, albeit one that has a good plausible ring to it.

3 edits


I can see no good reason to leave the EU and is a vote based on lies and misinformation really democracy? As far as I'm concerned the UK has run it"s course as a political entity and as a Scot I hope we'll be saying adieu asap.

1 edit

-Removed-
No. You tried to compare/conflate a bureaucrat with an elected representative, disingenuously I would say [in view of your obvious political literacy] in order to make a Daily Mail-esque debating point. The Brexit case can be made without resort to things like The Kinnock Meme, I think. 😉

1 edit


-Removed-
Kinnock's role ~ being a commissioner and not a legislator or minister ~ was to manage the implementation of the decisions made by those who held power and not to "make the decisions and hold power" as you continue to suggest. 😉


Originally posted by Rank outsider
So tacitly admitting that if they cannot achieve their means democratically, they are happy to do so undemocratically. As demonstrated by the fact that they are already agitating to ignore the referendum result.
The Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, who will extricate the country - or at least begin to do so - from the European Union, will now be selected by a simple majority of the - what is it now? - the 175,000 paid up members of the Conservative Party around the towns and shires of Britain, so I think there might be more than one undemocratic mechanism in play at the moment. 🙂


1 edit


-Removed-
I certainly think a case can be made for a democratic deficit but it is surely that legislators of other countries passed legislation that affected the British people rather than because of what commissioners did. It would be like slamming British democracy because it has an unelected civil service. 😉


-Removed-
That Cameron resigned instantly, with 4 years left of his mandate, and handed a decision about who should be the PM at this time to 90,000 members of his party, will have been absolutely scandalous IF the very first thing the new PM does ISN'T to call an immediate General Election.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by tunnock
I can see no good reason to leave the EU and is a vote based on lies and misinformation really democracy? As far as I'm concerned the UK has run it"s course as a political entity and as a Scot I hope we'll be saying adieu asap.
Before the Scottish referendum most Scots that wanted to leave the union cited Norway as an example of a relatively small populated country that is doing well economically .
Norway is not a member of the EU .
When you get independence from the union ,and I hope you do, Scotland will have to try a strike its own deal with the EU ( if the EU is still around ) and there will be no free prescriptions and university free -bees from Westminster .
Good luck .


Originally posted by phil3000
Before the Scottish referendum most Scots that wanted to leave the union cited Norway as an example of a relatively small populated country that is doing well economically .
Norway is not a member of the EU .
When you get independence from the union ,and I hope you do, Scotland will have to try a strike its own deal with the EU ( if the EU is still around ...[text shortened]... nd there will be no free prescriptions and university free -bees from Westminster .
Good luck .
Norway is however a member of the EEA with free access to the internal market and free movement of people. Examples of European countries which are not are Albania, Macedonia and Serbia. Maybe the UK will be able to have some free trade agreements with them?