@fmf saidIt is the foundation of Christian belief, and you have to ask? We must be born again,
Thanks for the clarification. But it's also a dodge, right. The post you were ostensibly replying to was this:
Are you claiming that completely evil people, like you have claimed you are, are rewarded with immortality - even if they continue to be evil - for their religious beliefs - you are claiming this is "justice"?
that is not human effort; it is a work of God in us, not us thinking happy thoughts all
about God, doing things in God's name, not doing things to be good enough, it is
relation with God doing in us a sanctifying work, making us more like Christ by
Christ being in us. Jesus said He was the Way, Truth, and the Life; it is simple without
Him, we are not saved, we need Jesus not something like Jesus, but Jesus.
16 May 22
@kellyjay saidI am asking because you seem incapable of making it sound coherent. I am asking you about your belief and asking you to take responsibility for whatever you espouse. Referring to it as "the foundation of Christian belief" and asking if I "have to ask" ...on a discussion forum... is just you being evasive.
It is the foundation of Christian belief, and you have to ask?
16 May 22
@kellyjay saidThese sentences you have typed are very generic and clearly not aimed at addressing my specific point.
We must be born again,
that is not human effort; it is a work of God in us, not us thinking happy thoughts all
about God, doing things in God's name, not doing things to be good enough, it is
relation with God doing in us a sanctifying work, making us more like Christ by
Christ being in us. Jesus said He was the Way, Truth, and the Life; it is simple without
Him, we are not saved, we need Jesus not something like Jesus, but Jesus.
Are you claiming that this is "justice": ...
Completely evil people, as you have described yourself, are rewarded with immortality despite continuing to be evil and do evil - due to their religious beliefs pertaining to them declaring themselves "forgiven".
That's "justice" is it?
@kellyjay said[1] You have called my lack of Christian belief "evil"; who are my "victims"?
If evil is rewarded, its victims are left without justice, which is, in my opinion, far
worse in an eternal Kingdom where love is the supreme ethic.
[2] If you believe some evil act you committed against someone is "forgiven" by your God figure, how is that "justice" for your victim?
@fmf saidI'm saying the reason I am justified is in Jesus Christ, not me; for my part, it is serving
I am asking because you seem incapable of making it sound coherent. I am asking you about your belief and asking you to take responsibility for whatever you espouse. Referring to it as "the foundation of Christian belief" and asking if I "have to ask" ...on a discussion forum... is just you being evasive.
and obeying the Lord, but He is the Redeemer. My part is laying down my life, picking
up the cross, and following Him. This is Biblical doctrine; it is not anything new; if it is
incoherent to you, how do you claim to understand my beliefs?
@fmf saidWhy don't you try to give specifics when you claim I have said something? Quote me.
[1] You have called my lack of Christian belief "evil"; who are my "victims"?
[2] If you believe some evil act you committed against someone is "forgiven" by your God figure, how is that "justice" for your victim?
I often say one thing, and you and dive come back and accuse me of saying
something you think I mean when that is not true. If you ask me to justify something I
said, quote it so I know the context.
@kellyjay saidYou seem to be peddling your bicycle as quickly as possible away from your odd notion of "justice".
I'm saying the reason I am justified is in Jesus Christ, not me; for my part, it is serving
and obeying the Lord, but He is the Redeemer. My part is laying down my life, picking
up the cross, and following Him.
@kellyjay saidYou have described yourself as "wicked" and "evil" countless times over the years. You even admitted very recently that you had done so when PB1022 called you out for it. Now, it may have been some disingenuous rhetorical false modesty on your part, but if you want to state unequivocally now that you are not evil and you are not wicked, then go ahead.
Why don't you try to give specifics when you claim I have said something?
@kellyjay saidIf you do not believe that all human beings are so evil that they deserve to be tortured for eternity after they die, including you, then say so, now. Yes, I know you believe you are "forgiven". But a pivotal point for your views on evil has always been that we are all evil, you, me, everybody.
I often say one thing, and you and dive come back and accuse me of saying
something you think I mean when that is not true.
@kellyjay saidIt doesn't matter if it's a doctrine you got from a leaflet you read in a dentist's waiting room, if you cannot render it morally coherent in the context of discourse, then the fact you believe it, in and of itself, is evidence of nothing much, aside from the nature of your own mindmap.
This is Biblical doctrine; it is not anything new; if it is
incoherent to you, how do you claim to understand my beliefs?
@fmf saidCorrect, we are all sinners and have fallen short; we all need a redeemer; we cannot
You have described yourself as "wicked" and "evil" countless times over the years. You even admitted very recently that you had done so when PB1022 called you out for it. Now, it may have been some disingenuous rhetorical false modesty on your part, but if you want to state unequivocally now that you are not evil and you are not wicked, then go ahead.
do it ourselves. It is a condition we all share, including me. There is nothing
disingenuous about that, no false modesty claiming I need Christ to save me
because I cannot do it myself and declaring no one else can either. Nothing about
that makes me better than anyone else; only Christ can do that. If you think you are
fine just the way you are, there is pride there.