23 Jan '11 10:48>6 edits
I'm sure not only Robbie Carrobie holds that lying is always bad (because the Bible says so); my question is why??? to this end perhaps someone will point out where in these examples telling the truth would be a better solution:
Dave: "Hi Greg!...how you doing?"
Me: (having only had a couple of hours sleep, am in a hurry to get somewhere Dave isn't, and have just had some crappy news that bears little relevance to the troubles Dave might be having or his reason for wanting to swap pleasantries) "Hi Dave, I'm not so bad thanksReveal Hidden Content
*small talk continues and ends in due course; neither of us have any impressions about the other they are a "miserable sod", and perhaps we should avoid them next time we see each other
Hooded stranger winding his way inside my comfort zone: "ere mate...got any cigs ah can lend off ya?"
Me: (with a couple of cigarettes left that I don't want to be giving away to strangers and not wanting to engage this person in dialogue, or *share* anything else) "No sorry mate...don't smokeReveal Hidden Content
Hooded manReveal Hidden Content
Some four year old child, Liam, showing me it's latest crayon scrawlings: "Look it's a cat!"
Me: (noticing it looks more like a trail of spaghetti than anything which remotely bears any resemblence to an animal - let alone a cat) "Wow that's really goodReveal Hidden Content
Liam: (now with a beaming grin on his face): "yeah they're it's whiskers!"
Me: "Well done Liam - have you showed it your mummy?"
Four year old merrily tootles off towards his mum looking for more approval of his "talents".
Dave: "Hi Greg!...how you doing?"
Me: (having only had a couple of hours sleep, am in a hurry to get somewhere Dave isn't, and have just had some crappy news that bears little relevance to the troubles Dave might be having or his reason for wanting to swap pleasantries) "Hi Dave, I'm not so bad thanksReveal Hidden Content
a lie
...and you?"
*small talk continues and ends in due course; neither of us have any impressions about the other they are a "miserable sod", and perhaps we should avoid them next time we see each other
Hooded stranger winding his way inside my comfort zone: "ere mate...got any cigs ah can lend off ya?"
Me: (with a couple of cigarettes left that I don't want to be giving away to strangers and not wanting to engage this person in dialogue, or *share* anything else) "No sorry mate...don't smokeReveal Hidden Content
making sure the cuboidal bulge in my pocket is obscured from his line of sight
"
Hooded manReveal Hidden Content
(who isn\'t closing the distance between myself and him as fast as he\'s walking - since I\'m now starting to back away)
: "k, safe mate"
Some four year old child, Liam, showing me it's latest crayon scrawlings: "Look it's a cat!"
Me: (noticing it looks more like a trail of spaghetti than anything which remotely bears any resemblence to an animal - let alone a cat) "Wow that's really goodReveal Hidden Content
I secretly think it\'s horrible and that drawing is probably not playing to his strengths
- are those it's whiskers!?"
Liam: (now with a beaming grin on his face): "yeah they're it's whiskers!"
Me: "Well done Liam - have you showed it your mummy?"
Four year old merrily tootles off towards his mum looking for more approval of his "talents".